AllFreeNovel
Share Us
Andrew motioned towards the living room. “Can we sit? Jesse’s asleep, by the way. He tried to wait up for you but he couldn’t do it.”
Walking to the couch, I sank into it and continued staring at them with wide eyes. Andrew sat on one side of me and pulled my hand into his lap. “What the hell?”
Caleb sat next to me and kicked his ankle over his knee. “We talked about you while you were in class. After Jesse fell asleep. No trauma for the kid, I guess.”
“Okay… I talked about early childhood education but you don’t see me kissing it. Much less me and my two best friends. What are y’all doing?”
Jack held up a finger. “I haven’t kissed you yet.”
“Yet?!” I pressed my hand to my forehead and took in a few gulping inhales of air. “Yet?”
Andrew sat forward and gripped his hands together between his knees. “We all want a chance with you. We’ve never wanted the same woman before and none of us are willing to back down.”
I stared at him with my mouth ajar. He couldn’t be serious.
“You can pick any one of us, Olive.” Jack shrugged like he was offering me pumpkins at the pumpkin patch.
“You’re not apples! What do you mean, I can pick any one of you? Have you all lost your mind?” I stood up and planted my hands on my hips. “I mean… I mean, it’s crazy. People don’t just offer themselves up to people.”
Caleb shrugged just as casually as his roommate had. “We are. Offering ourselves up, that is. Do you need to sample the goods before you make your decision?”
“You’ve all lost your minds. I’m not choosing one of you. I can’t do that. I-”
Andrew tugged me into his chest and sat with me on his lap sideways. “Let’s start with the easy stuff. Are you attracted to us?”
My cheeks burned hot and I opened and closed my mouth a few times. “You’re just asking me these questions like it’s easy for me to answer them. This is crazy.”
Andrew pinched my chin between his fingers and turned my face to his. “If we’re wrong about all of this, just say the words. We’ll all apologize and pretend like this never happened if that would make you feel better.”
Jack sat on the couch next to us. “This part is easy, Olive. Are you attracted to us?”
I licked my bone-dry lips and groaned. “Yes! Yes, okay? I’m attracted to three men at the same time. Maybe some of those names they used to call me were accurate. I mean…three men at once…”
Jack tugged me onto his lap so I was straddling him and then he pulled my mouth to his. He was kissing me in front of Andrew and Caleb while I straddled him and the world wasn’t ending. The sense of horrible shame I expected to weigh on me didn’t. Instead, I felt…beyond turned on.
He held my head in one hand and my hip in the other and he kissed me deep, stroking his tongue past my lips. He tasted like mint chocolate and he seemed to like my taste as he moaned against my lips. “Fuck, Olive. You’re none of those bad names.”
I rested my hand on his chest and lifted my head. I was high on desire that quickly. I’d never felt it so intensely before, if at all. Looking from him to Caleb and Andrew, I rocked my hips forward on Jack to relieve some of the tension building at my core. “This… I’ve never… I don’t know how to choose.”
Andrew leaned forward and kissed my shoulder. “We could make a game out of it. You know? Keep it easy and light.”
Caleb nodded along. “Yeah… Like, who does it better? And you don’t have to choose right away.”
Jack dropped his head back on the couch and looked up at me through half-lidded eyes. “Yes,that. We each kiss you and you can see whose kiss you like better. That’ll help you make a decision.”
I wasn’t sure if they were making sense, or if none of us were, but it suddenly sounded like a really great idea. My body was humming for them in ways it never had and I didn’t want it to stop. “That seems fair.”
“Fair is important.” Andrew nodded along. “We wouldn’t want it any other way.”
14
***Olive***
Jackpulledmymouthback to his and hesitated when our breath mingled with just a hair of space between our lips. “You can tell us to stop at any time, Olive.”
I ran my hands through his short hair and watched his eyelids flutter when my nails raked over his scalp. I liked seeing his reactions. That was new for me. I didn’t want anything to stop. I wanted to kiss them all and pretend like it was for some test to see who was better.
Sensing that I wasn’t interested in stopping, Jack gripped my hair and kissed me. His lips were firm as he moved them over mine. When I felt his other hand grip my ass and pull me even closer, I gasped and he slid his tongue over my parted lips. With my knees planted on the couch on either side of his hips, my center pressed hotly against his. When he pulled me closer, my legging covered core rubbed over a hard ridge that felt too good under me. I rocked myself against it, lust drunk and unconcerned about Andrew and Caleb watching.
