AllFreeNovel
Share Us
She nods slowly, and whispers, “It was positive. One of you is going to be a father.”
I hope it’s me, but I can see Commando hopes the same thing, so I don’t say a word, other than to offer unwavering support.
“We’re here for you, Cheri.” I extend my arms, and she steps into my embrace, looking up at me.
“How did you know?”
“Mostly I just sensed it. I guess there are some things you just know, like I know that I love you, Cheri.”
She looks skeptical of my declaration. “We had amazing sex, but we barely know each other. How can you love me?”
Commando speaks for both of us when he says, “It was confusing when I came into the diner that day and Avery played matchmaker. Even more confusing when we found out you’re our stepsister. And there’s the seventeen-year age gap. And you being adamant about not having a relationship with us. But we don’t want what happens on the island to stay on the island. We want a life with you.”
“You can’t know that,” she argues.
I add, “You don’t get to say what we can and can’t know. I’ve been with other women, not that I want to think about them right now, but I know how they made me feel. It’s why I’m still single. I’ve never once felt like I do with you.”
My brothers and I have each other’s back, for a common cause: to make her ours, to make it clear that she belongs to us, to all of us.
Even Stonewall speaks up. “Love is the only explanation for why I couldn’t contain myself during your derby bout. I need you, Cheri, and I’m sorry I held back. I had to get my shit together, but I can admit that now. I’m still working on it, but that’s because of you. You make me want more out of life.”
Commando says, “Whether you want us or not, please tell us we’re Daddies. Say it again, for real.”
She’s wide-eyed as she gulps and nods. “Well, one of you is. I really thought I couldn’t get pregnant.”
I say, “My sweet, innocent little stepslut, we coated you inside and out with baby batter. What did you expect would happen?”Before she can take offense or misunderstand my intent, I continue. “Having a baby with you will be the best thing that’s ever happened to me, to any of us.” I don’t mind speaking for my brothers in this case, because I know they agree.
She nibbles on her lower lip. “Full disclosure… I would never have unprotected sex with someone I didn’t think I could be forever bound to.”
It’s her first admission that doesn’t hold resistance. Happiness blasts through me.
“You mean that?” I bend to kiss her lips tenderly. When I pull away, I say, “Even if the baby’s not mine, I want you in my life forever. And I’m damn sure going to keep trying to give you a baby.”
“I don’t know what to say.”
Commando tucks a finger under her chin and angles her head up to him. “Say you’ll move in with us. We’re here for you. We’re all going to start our military out-processing as soon as our leave is over.”
She gasps. To be honest, I’m also surprised my brothers and I could make that decision, but we talked about it before we came.
“You don’t have to give up your jobs for me! I don’t want you to regret any of this.”
Stonewall says, “The only thing I regret is that there’s no chance you’re pregnant with my baby.”
I add, “We’re a package deal. We would destroy each other if you only chose one or two.”
She nods slowly, studying the three of us. “So you all are okay with this, a relationship between the four of us?”
“We do everything together, even share our little stepslut.”
Cheri turns to Stonewall. “Really?”
“I’ve already waited too long,” Stonewall declares, lifting her up. Her legs wrap around his waist, her arms around his neck, and their lips meet. He lifts her a little higher and reachesunderneath her ass to unbutton his pants. “I’m going to take you right now.”
“What if someone walks in?”
Commando tests the door. “There’s not a lock, but I’ll hold the handle.”
I step behind my stepslut, eager to share her with Stonewall for the first time. I tuck my fingers into her panties and pull them to the side, giving my fingers ample contact to rub through her wetness. “Want me to hold these out of the way?”
