The butt plug was a good start, but it was much smaller than my cock. I want to start with more prep to make sure Noelle has time to adjust. She lets out a soft whimper, pushing her ass up as I slowly press the tip of my finger inside.
“Oh fuck,” Noelle breathes, hanging her head.
“Too much?” I ask, holding perfectly still. “Want me to stop?”
She shakes her head, panting. “No. Keep going.”
I ease my finger in deeper, mindful of every movement. I want this moment to be branded into her memory, a reminder of how deeply she craves my touch. Once my finger is fully seated, I carefully add in a second, scissoring my fingers to open her wider. I must hit a particularly sensitive spot because she arches back, gasping audibly.
Fuck, she’s so damn tight, and knowing my dick will be inside soon is enough to turn me into a primal beast.
“Feel that, Noelle? Those are my fingers fucking your ass, and soon, you’ll be full of my cock,” I murmur, leaning in to ghost my lips along her back.
“More,” she begs.
When I’m able to slide my fingers in and out easily, I know she’s ready for me.
“I’ll start with the tip and slowly work myself in all the way. If at any point you want me to stop, tell me, and I will.”
She nods, pushing her hips up to meet mine. I pour a generous amount of lube down the crease between her cheeks and rub my dick across it until we’re both super slick.
I set the lube aside and grab the bullet from the edge of the mattress, placing it in Noelle’s hand. Since she’s blindfolded, I wait until her hand closes around it before releasing my hold.
“Is this what I think it is?” she asks, running her fingers along the smooth cylinder.
“If you guessed a vibrator, you’re right. I want you to tease your clit while I play with your ass. Think you can do that?”
“Mm-hmm.”
I lean down to press several kisses along her spine. “That’s my good girl.”
I want her to focus on making herself feel good while she takes me—that means toeing the line between pleasure and taking her to new heights.
A low hum fills the room, telling me she’s turned on the device, and she shudders slightly when the tip touches her clit, arching into me. She holds herself up with her free forearm planted firmly on the mattress.
“Just like that.”
I take hold of my cock and press the tip against her back entrance, easing my way past the initial resistance. She fits around me like a damn glove, and the world shrinks to her ragged breaths and the heat clawing through me.
“You’re so big,” Noelle moans.
“Breathe, sweetheart.” I coach her as I caress the curve of her waist. “Breathe and let me in.”
I inhale deeply, and it takes all my willpower to work inside her inch by inch, until my hips are pressed against hers. Noelle writhes beneath me as I stay still for several seconds, letting her feel the full stretch of me. Fuck, it drives me wild knowing I’m the only man who’s ever claimed her here.
“You’re doing great, baby,” I praise. “Put more pressure on your clit.”
She bobs her head as she does what she’s told, the low hum of the device building to a steady purr, her free hand clutching the comforter as she groans.
Noelle lets out a pleading whimper. “Move, Shep. I need you to move.”
Unable to deny her, I withdraw slightly, then slide forward in slow, measured strokes.
Desire hums between us, electric and unrelenting, the space dissolving into nothing but our bodies pressed together and our ragged breaths. I rub my other hand along her damp skin, keeping her in position.
Noelle’s movements grow more insistent as she begins pushing back into me, soft gasps spilling from her lips. I can feel her muscles relax around me, and I pull out halfway before thrusting forward, burying myself to the hilt. I maintain a steady rhythm, gliding back and forth while she holds the vibrator in place.
“You’re taking me so well. You love playing with yourself while I claim your ass, don’t you, baby?”
