I peek my eyes open to see him openly staring at me, devouring me with his eyes. When I glance to my left, I see Jeremy doing the same.
Jeremy glides through the water until he’s right in front of me, I stare into his almost black eyes.
“I think we should have some fun,” Jeremy whispers then drags me over towards Jay.
When he gives Jay a nod, he hops up on the ledge, giving me the perfect angle to suck him off. I lean forward eagerly, taking him in my mouth. My ass is in the air, a little above the water, hopefully taunting Jeremy.
“You mentioned you can get inside people’s minds, do you think you’ve done it before?” He pauses before continuing, “because I haven’t had a chance yet to punish you for leaving us.”
He smacks my ass, hard.
“It was real!” I shout, popping off of Jay. The dream with Jeremy actually happened!
He laughs but it’s a little taunting, “I guess it was but if your ass wasn’t sore the next day it doesn’t count.”
He spanks me again, this time once on each cheek.
“I have accelerated healing now, either way I won’t feel it the next day,” I point out but that doesn’t stop him from doing it again.
“Don’t ignore Jay, you owe him an apology too.”
I bring my lips back down and around Jay’s cock. He threads his fingers through my hair and forces me to take him deeper.
When he’s pressing against the back of my throat, Jeremy spanks me again, causing me to take Jay even deeper.
“Fuck Aly Kat, you are so damn sexy. You’re forgiven,” Jay groans but I know it’s not him who’s calling the shots right now. I’m not forgiven until Jeremy says I am.
I can feel him line up behind me, giving me a second of warning before he slams into me. I swallow around Jay as he’s taken even further down my throat.
He’s swearing up a storm and I think he’s close to coming for me.
Jeremy sets a brutal pace as he thrusts into me, he’s fucking me so hard he sets the pace for Jay too. I can feel his piercing tracing against all my nerves.
I can feel Jay swell in my mouth seconds before he’s coming down mt throat. His fingers in my hair tighten as I swallow every drop of him, knowing he loves that. It’s part of how possessive he is of me.
As soon as I’m off of Jay, Jeremy laces his fingers with mine before putting them on the edge of the tub so Jay is still between them. He keeps our fingers locked as he ruts into me, hitting my g spot but not letting me come. Every time I get close he switches angles until he builds me up again. He’s using that piercing against me to keep me on edge.
Jay sits back on the edge to watch the show and his eyes on me almost push me over the edge. Almost.
“Jeremy please!” I beg.
“Are you sorry for being a bad girl?” He asks and while it was definitely not my fault, I’ll do anything to come right now.
“Yes, so sorry!”
“Promise it’ll never happen again,” he demands and I groan.
“I promise!”
He switches angles until every stroke is pure bliss as his piercing hits me in the most amazing spot. Even better, he doesn’t move when he feels me tighten around him.
I explode, all the denied orgasms making this one even more incredible. I swear I see stars when I come and I bet I wake the other three up I’m screaming so loud.
Jeremy finishes with me, grinding into me as he does.
I almost collapse but the two of them catch me before I hit the water.
“I think you’re ready for bed now,” Jay says, picking me up out of the water and carrying me inside.
