“Good.” Luke steeples his fingers before his lips. “Our turn. Jack.”
“Never have I ever kissed four guys in one day.”
My eyebrows rise as Jack takes off a sock. I blush as I lean down and take off a sock too.
“Okay, explain?” I look directly at Jack’s blue eyes.
“I’m bi, sweetheart. And I’ve played spin the bottle where it’s only been men.” He shrugs like it’s not that big a deal.
“Have you ever with…” I glance at the other horsemen, who all laugh.
“Kissed one of them, yes. Fucked any of them, no. They’re all straight as arrows.” Jack leans back. Now I’m curious who kissed Jack. “Your turn to ask.”
“Never have I had a threesome.” I bite my lip and watch them.
Everyone but Luke stands up and removes a sock.
“Never?” I raise my eyebrow at Luke. “Come on. Not even two girls and you? I’m not believing this.”
Luke leans in, blue eyes flashing. “Never, princess. I rarely like sharing attention.”
I cross my legs against the involuntary throb provoked by his words. I swallow and focus on the others.
“I know Caden and Jack tag-teamed Parker Ford, but have you with anyone else?” I don’t know why I’m asking. It will only hurt more to know they’ve done all this before.
“A few.” Caden brushes his fingers over his lips. “But mostly to get the technique down. It’s not as easy as it looks in porn.”
My eyebrows rise at that. I clear the lump from my throat. “And you, Eli?”
“Jack and I have done the same girl at the same time.” He doesn’t elaborate. Probably for the best. The heat in my chest doesn’t feel like gentle desire, more like raging anger.
I wonder what girls in our school they’ve had a threesome with and if those girls are looking at me as if I’m going to join their ranks. Maybe there’s a support group for girls who got fucked by multiple horsemen.
“My turn.” Luke’s gaze rakes over me. “Never have I ever watched porn.”
All the guys stand up. Caden and Luke remove a sock. Eli removes his watch. Jack removes his jeans. They all look at me expectantly.
I sigh and reach down to yank off my other sock.
They all give me knowing looks.
“Look, even I’m curious. You don’t have to have sex to watch sex.” I arch an eyebrow at them.
“See anything you like?” Jack asks.
“Not particularly.” I have no reason to lie about this. “Personally, I don’t get watching porn. I mean, it was hard enough to find a guy that didn’t look skeezy, and then it just looked very methodical. Like insert tab B into slot A, move to position two, and continue.” I shrug and admit, “I prefer reading steamy romance or erotic romance.”
“Any recommendations, sweetheart?” Jack winks.
“Ha, no. If you want to read romance, you can find your own books to read.” I lean back and stare at the guys. What else do I want to know?
“Ticktock, kitten.” Eli pulls my attention to him.
Pretty sure this one will have them all stripping.
“Never have I ever had a one-night stand.” I wait for them all to take off something.
Caden and Eli take off their shirts, while Jack loses his boxer briefs. Of course his cock is hard. I think I’m becoming immune to seeing his cock. This is, what, the third time? He strokes it with his hand and my core throbs.
