Page 50 of My First Mistake

Page List
Font Size:

I lay her down on the couch when she’s done and go grab the lube. The bottle is sealed, which is reassuring, and when I get back into the living room, she’s already lying on her front with her ass on display for me. Something about the way the red lace of her thong disappears between her cheeks does something feral to me. I climb on top of her, pulling her long, dark hair out of my way so I can pepper her back and shoulders with kisses. “Have you had sex like this before?” I ask, wondering how much prepping she’ll need.

“Yeah.”

I push myself up onto my knees and tap her juicy ass. “Bend over the arm of the couch for me then.”

She does as she’s told, wiggling that perfect peach seductively as she does. I leave her thong on and pull it to the side and then I coat two fingers with a generous amount of lube.

“Spread your legs for me, baby.”

She shuffles her knees apart, the tips of her heels grazing my thighs and her ass opening up for me, until I can see her pretty hole. The couch creaks as I move between her legs, sliding my finger over her entrance and pushing gently past the tight ring of muscle.

Her back bows as she moans softly.

“That okay?” I check in with her.

Her confirmation is a soft, sultry “yeah” that spurs me on. Her ass squeezes me tight as I push all the way to the knuckle,twisting and opening her up for me. When she groans with pleasure, I take it as my cue to add a second. I push past the resistance until I have two fingers knuckle deep inside her.

“You still feel good, Addie?”

She nods, gasping. “Yes, Chase. I’m ready.”

“Ready for my cock?”

“Please!”

Holy fuck! If anyone had told me at the start of this week that Addie Kinsella would be bent over a sofa begging me to fuck her ass I would have told them they were insane. And yet here we are, her pushing that juicy ass back for more and my cock aching to be inside her.

I add plenty of lube to my shaft. Despite knowing how much she wants this, I’m still nervous about hurting her. So, I add a generous squeeze of the lube to her asshole as well, and she squeals at the cold gel on her skin.

“Sorry, baby.” I grab hold of her hips and nudge my crown at her entrance. “I don’t want to hurt you.”

She glances over her shoulder and gives me a sexy smile. “I know you won’t. I trust you.”

It’s her trust that really unravels me, even more than her sexy body. Even if I don’t deserve it, I’ll take it anyway. My eyes roll back when I push gently inside her, and her ass muscles clamp around the tip of my cock. There’s no chance in hell I’ll be able to bottom out inside her, but even if I don’t, this is enough.

“Chase!” she cries out in pleasure.

“My cock in your ass feels good?”

“Yes! Yes!” she chants.

“Rub your clit for me, I want to make you come like this.”

Always obedient when I’m fucking her, she does as she’s told. Her hand snaking between her thighs. I’m not going to last long with the way she’s squeezing me, so I keep a tight grip on her hips and slow my movements. Just long enough until I feel heron the edge with me. And when she comes, the vibrations from her pussy rippling travel to my cock and I sink deeper, harder.

“Fuck, Addie.” I empty myself inside her, endorphins charging around my body. And I stay inside her for a few moments, planting kisses on her back and enjoying the sensation of my warm cum filling her ass.

“That was intense,” she murmurs.

“Yeah,” I agree. Then I pull her to lie down beside me on the sofa, envelop her in my arms and rest my lips on the top of her head. “Thank you.”

“No, thank you,” she laughs softly, burrowing into my chest. “Who knew me wearing nothing but my heels and panties would get you so riled up?”

I resist the urge to swat her ass and instead pull her closer. “Seeing as how I spent three hours in my meeting today instead of one, I think I owe you. How do you feel about a soak in the bath while I make dinner?”

The sound that comes out of her sounds like a cat purring. “I feel all kinds of happy about that kind of evening.”

“Good.” I kiss the top of her head. “As soon as I can feel my legs again, I’ll go run you a bath.”