Page 42 of It Could Have Been Her

Page List
Font Size:

There, immediately, is the face of a man who I take to be Grandad Allen: a stern-looking man with a dark mustache and a very slim physique. In the first photograph, he has been caught unawares, pruning shears in one gloved hand, a cigarette in the other, a fully blossomed rosebush behind him. He’s wearing a white shirt, unbuttoned to reveal an undershirt, and is looking at the photographer with barely disguised annoyance.

In the picture beneath he is posing in the same garden scene, wearingthe same clothes, but this time he is smiling into the lens, his arms folded across his stomach. In the background I can see the blurred figure of a young woman, staring across the garden toward the photographer. I can’t tell who it is. I feel it must be Jessamine, but something doesn’t seem right about the set of the figure’s shoulders or the shape of the face.

On the next page are photos of Jessamine and, I assume, Jasper. They appear to be teenage, or on the cusp of teenage. They sit on stools at the kitchen table and look as though they weren’t expecting to be photographed. Jessamine wears blue trousers and a white T-shirt. Jasper wears a T-shirt with a photograph of a clown on the front, and a pair of jeans. Both children look drawn. There are dark circles around their eyes, and what looks like bruising to the side of Jessamine’s face.

I flip faster and faster through the album, trying to piece things together. There are photos of an elderly lady who wears her white hair in a topknot, and photos of Annie when she was much younger—and very attractive: the looker of the family, it is clear. There are photos of Allen looking stern and vaguely annoyed, and then photos of Jessamine and Jasper when they were older, still looking tired, Jasper appearing increasingly unhinged, his thick hair grown out into an unruly mop, his eyes slightly wild, his face often blurred as if caught in the act of movement. Jessamine is thin and unkempt, while Annie shines at her side in designer clothes and coiffed hair.

Then I turn the page and there is a photo of the older man, the one with the mustache who I take to be Allen. He is wearing a tweed jacket with a packet of cigarettes poking out of the breast pocket. And in his arms is a beautiful gray cat. I stare at the cat, and even though the last time I saw this cat it was an emaciated sack of bones sucked dry of life in a black plastic bag, I know that this is the same one, this is Tina. A terrible bolt of sadness and darkness runs through me.

There’s a dead cat in the shed.

The way Annie had said it, as if it was just any cat. Not their cat. Not a family pet. And here is said cat, alive and well and in the arms of Annie’shusband. There is warmth in the way he holds the cat, visible affection. How long, I wonder, how long had Tina been in that shed? And how aware was Annie of the fact that she was there? I pull the photo out of the album and turn it over. In ballpoint pen on the back it says: “Allen and Bella. 2001.” Bella then, but she will always be Tina to me. And even assuming she was young in this shot and lived until she was twenty, she would have died at least five years ago.

I push the photo back into the album and turn the next page, but the album ends abruptly, a few empty leaves left unfilled. I shut it and put it back in the cabinet.

chapter thirty-three

Jane follows the little blue dot on her Maps app showing her location on the Heath. She’s currently heading on foot down a narrow, graveled pathway between an imposing mansion block and the Italianate frontage of a stucco villa with a wrought-iron balcony that overlooks the deep dip of Hampstead Heath. According to the Land Registry map, this path will eventually meet up with a much smaller path that should, if the drawing is accurate, connect her to the very back end of Thornwood.

This corner of the Heath is mysterious and feels strangely uncharted. There are no dog walkers here and very little sunshine gets through the thick green canopy of leaves overhead. Jane can see the rooftops of the villas and cottages of the Vale just below her to the right, but the map takes her in the other direction, through narrower paths and denser foliage, down a very steep slope, and there, in front of her, she sees the distinctive tiled roof of Thornwood.

The land is fenced at the back, but the slats are rotten and flapping away from each other. It’s easy to pull one panel partly open and to squeeze through. She can see the back of the house from here, through a mess of overgrown rosebushes, bony apple trees, outhouses, neglected vegetable patches, and fallen trellises. She can only imagine what thisgarden must have looked like in its prime, when it was being properly tended.

She makes her way down a side path, away from view of the cottage. At the back of the house is a ramshackle conservatory, old plant shelving rusting on York stone slabs outside. The interior of the conservatory is messy and unkempt. To the right of the conservatory is a door that looks as though it leads into a kitchen. Through the window next to it, Jane can see a cluttered windowsill, old-fashioned curtains, a dark wood dresser against a pale green wall.

She pulls out her phone and takes photographs. Farther along she sees the dimpled opaque glass of what must be a toilet or a bathroom, and to the other side of the house she sees an outhouse attached to the external wall. She heads around the back of the garden again and then toward the outhouse.

It is small, about ten feet square, and has a metal door with a padlock on the outside. The padlock, as she gets closer to it, appears to be open. She glances around herself and then upward toward the first-floor windows, but doesn’t sense anyone’s eyes on her, so she pulls the padlock gently open and eases the metal door toward her. It makes a terrible grinding sound as she does so, and she flinches and squeezes her eyes shut. She stops and looks around again, but nobody seems to have heard. When she pulls again, the door makes another small squeak and then opens, revealing a chilling sight.

A solitary chair, metal with a ripped vinyl seat, and there, on the walls on either side of the chair, a pair of metal rings, screwed into the walls. Jane steps into the outhouse and takes some photos; then, gingerly, she sits on the dirty old chair. She stretches out her arms, and gasps when she sees that they reach perfectly, on each side, to the metal rings.

chapter thirty-four

Her stomach turns with horror and disgust, and she jumps to her feet and pushes through the metal door, out into the perfect limpid air of the May morning, breathing in deeply to quell a terrible wave of nausea.

Allen Black’s face races across her mind’s eye, his back to her as he mixed her drink, the tightness of his jaw when she knocked it from his hand.

Had she drunk the martini that night back in the year 2000, she thinks, she would have ended up in that room, on that chair, shackled to those walls, she knows it, she justknowsit. She bends in half, her fist pushed deep into her stomach, certain that she is about to throw up, but then from the house there is a low rumble, building quickly and dramatically into a succession of high-pitched barks, the sound of claws scampering hard and fast over York stone and heading straight toward her. Hugo. Of course. She doesn’t turn to look at him, just runs as fast as she can up the side path of the garden to the very back, where she jumps through the gap in the broken fence and pushes it back into place. On the other side of the fence she can hear Hugo’s insistent barking, his paws banging at the wood, his furious curiosity.

“Hugo!” she whispers from the other side. “It’s me. Jane.”

His barking stops and she hears a small whimper.

“Be a good boy and go back indoors. Good boy.”

He whimpers again, and then it is silent.

Distantly Jane hears Stuart’s voice. “What the fuck, Hugo? Chill. There’s nothing there.”

Jane holds her breath hard, and waits for a minute or two, then heads back through the depths of the Heath and out into the daylight, to the Hampstead ornamental pond gleaming in the sunshine, the shiny traffic in four directions, people, dogs, light.

In a pub called the White Swan a moment later, she orders herself a gin and tonic. It’s early for a drink but her nerves are shredded, her stomach is churning, and she needs something to absorb the shock waves. She has five minutes before her call from Oliver—yes, she remembered without her phone telling her—and she needs to gather herself. She squeezes the lemon slice into the drink and stirs it through, then takes a large slurp through a straw and readies herself to look at the photos of Thornwood on her phone. She swipes through them quickly until she gets to the photos of the interior of the outhouse. She thinks of the smell in there, the putrid green smell of moss and decay and damp, and she thinks of that chilling feeling of stretching her arms from wall to wall and realizing that they fitted. She sends the photos to Dexter with shocked-face emojis and the words “in Stuart’s back garden” and then she sees the time on her phone switch from 11:59 to 12:00 and calls Oliver.

“She was nuts,” says Oliver, and Jane immediately rankles. Only the worst men describe their exes as nuts and she knows this because she has, in her time,beendescribed as nuts—she was known as Mad Jane Trevally by some. But the best men she has been with never talked about her in derogatoryterms when their relationships broke down, and she includes both of her ex-husbands in that.

“Nuts?” she says circumspectly. “In what way?”

“Oh, just intense. Too much. You know.”