Ethan glances around and then leans against the wall across from the door. “Sure, go ahead.”
We close the door and lock it.
“That part was easy.” Penny walks over to the toilet and pulls her panties down.
“Whoa.” I turn my back on her.
“What? I really have to pee.”
I turn on the water to hide the sound of her peeing and to cover our voices. “Do you have the extra panties?”
“Yeah, this skirt has pockets.” She flushes the toilet and washes her hands in the running water. She turns to meet my eyes as I lean against the counter. “Are you sure you can do this? We can call it off right now. I can pretend to be sick and we can go back to the party.”
“No, I need to do this.” Can they humiliate him without me? Yes, but this will help solidify me as part of them—not just the chick they’re all banging—to everyone coming after us.
“Okay.” She checks the door leading into the other room to make sure it’s unlocked. Then she pulls out the extra panties. “Hurry.”
I slide the panties Caden wanted me to wear off and pull on the extra. Then I put back on the main pair. This was the part of the plan that I asked way too many questions about. Why didn’t I just wear two pairs of panties to begin with? Why didn’t I find a way to carry them? Why not leave an extra pair in this bathroom? Though there doesn’t seem to be anywhere to hide them. Why do I have to take them off in front of Ethan? And how on earth do I make him do what they want me to ask him to do?
Caden answered the first one by slipping his hand between my legs under the skirt and pressing the panties up against my pussy. “I want them to smell like you, little nympho. And now they’ll smell like me too.”
“Are you ready?” Penny wrings her hands. “Have you ever done anything like this before?”
I shake my head and smile. “Nope, but we’re going to get through this. You aren’t chickening out, right?”
“I’m good.” She smiles and tucks her hair behind her ear.
I take her hand and a deep breath, then open the door. Ethan steps away from the wall with a grin.
“Girls.”
I laugh like I’m nervous, which isn’t far from the truth. “We were talking, and if I’m going to risk getting punished, I want to do something I’ve never done before.”
His eyebrow goes up, but his smile is lecherous. “What do you want?”
“Let’s play truth or dare.” I give him a hopefully tempting smile.
“Oh, yes, let’s.” Penny grins at me as if I’m amazing.
He glances down the hallway both ways. It’s like I can see the hamster wheel turning in his head.
“Fine, but we can’t do it out here in the open.” Good. That means he’s still afraid of the horsemen. That means this should work.
“The bathroom?” I back into it and hold my hand out to show him how big it is.
He steps in after us and shuts the door. “Yeah, this will do nicely.”
“Sit down on the floor.” Both Penny and I wait until Ethan begins to lower himself before we sit across from him. Neither of us wants to give him any more ideas.
“Truth or dare, Harper.” Ethan’s blue eyes latch onto me.
“Truth.” The guys told me never to pick dare with Ethan. There’s no telling what he might make me do.
He smirks. “Have you really sucked all the horsemen’s cocks?”
“Yes.” I don’t hesitate with my answer. It doesn’t matter if he knows any of what I’ve done with them. That’s not the point of this.
I turn to Penny. “Truth or dare, Penny.”
