Page 4 of Only Time Will Tell

“Calm down, not with anyone but myself. You know I’d never cheat on you. I’ve been trying to get myself ready.” He tossed the bottle on the bed.

“Ready? I’m gonna need more words than that?” My cock stirred when the image of Charlie fingering himself hit me.

“Wanna watch?” He blew me a kiss and all the blood in my body rushed to my dick. I nodded. There were no words as I reached down to adjust myself. Charlie caught that and winked at me. Someone was sassy as fuck tonight.

He swayed his hips to the beat of whatever song played in his devious little mind. The seductive sway entranced me and I couldn’t look away. Irresistible, Charlie had always been to me, but his unabashed side left me hypnotized. He slid his shirt off and tossed it aside, then hooked his thumbs in the elastic waistband of his shorts, all the while still moving to the beat. Down his legs they went, and there he stood.

Naked. He’d gone commando.

My eyes roamed every inch of him. “Like what you see?”

“Fuck yeah, but…” Speechless, and not for the first time tonight.

“But what, Alex? Use your words,” Charlie teased.

“Can I—can I taste you?” I stuttered, licking my lips.

“Babe, you can taste me anytime you like.” He wiggled that sassy ass toward the bed. I gripped hips and slid my lips down his shaft. Now what? I’d never done more than tease the tip. Kinda didn’t think this through.

“Mmm, Alex, I know you can do better than that.”

The only option, given I couldn’t breathe, was to back off.

“Little by little, love,” he cooed, running his fingers through my hair and tracing his cockhead along my lips, outlining them. “Open wide.”

You can do this, Alex. Don’t. Fuck. It. Up.

This time, I paced myself, slowly taking him in inch by inch, not going any deeper when I started to gag. Huh, guess this wasn’t too different from football, just took more practice.

“Alex, your mouth feels sooo good. I can’t wait to see how great it feels to be buried inside you.”

His words both shocked and aroused me. I’d never seen this side of him before and I liked it.

Charlie grabbed a handful of my hair, guiding my head back and forth a couple of times. “You’re gonna make me come too fast.” He pushed me down on the bed and pulled my shorts off. Not sure where they landed and right now, couldn’t care less. He opened the lube as I slid back on the bed and spread my legs.

It was far more uncomfortable than I’d imagined when his finger breached the ring of muscle. I sucked in a breath, and he pulled his finger out and reached for the bottle and added more lube.

“Alex, clenching up is only going to make things worse,” Charlie whispered. Not sure if it was me, him or both of us he was being calm for. “I’m gonna try again. Please, relax for me.” He kissed the inside of my thigh as his finger pressed inside. “Alex, you’ve not had anything in here, have you?” I shook my head and covered my eyes to hide my embarrassment.

“This isn’t working.” Took a lot for me to admit that. Hell, even my dick was limp.

“Well then, I think for our first time you’ll be inside me,” he said so matter-of-factly it startled me.

“I…I don’t know what to do and I don’t want to hurt you,” I admitted, still covering my face. This was not going at all as I’d envisioned and I was ready to call it a night and admit defeat.

“Wanna see how I’ve practiced?” he asked as he sat back.

That grabbed my attention. I sat up so fast I got a headrush. “Fuck yeah, I do,” my previous embarrassment all but cast aside.

Charlie lay down and spread his legs wide while dousing his fingers with more lube. I sat there, staring as he slid his first finger in with such ease.

This was so fucking hot.

“You like watching this?” he teased, fingering himself.

“It’s hot as fuck,” I stroked my cock back to life as he worked in a second finger.

“Wanna try?” he asked.