Page 71 of Plug and Drain

Susie was silent for a long moment. He couldn’t see her face, but the drop of her head made his heart clench. When she spoke, her voice was timid again. “I don’t need you to be gentle.”

So, it wasn’t the first time someone had taken her ass. Susie was not a virgin in any respect.

Arken had suspected that Zott took liberties in training the students, but he had not realised the full extent of the man’s depraved methods.

I will have to do better.

But first…

His breathing grew shallow as he gazed down at Susie. He would not be the first man to take her ass, but it would be her first time with him, and that in itself was special.

Just as she was special to him—a realisation that was becoming apparent at an alarming rate.

He removed his thumb from her ass and pulled his cock out of her pussy. His shaft was engorged and slick with her juices, the vein on the underside prominent. And oh, how he yearned to sink it back into her. His entire body was primed, every muscle tense and ready to fuck.

His vision darkened at the edges until she was his sole focus. “You are such a good girl,” he whispered, spreading her ass cheeks with his hand and pushing the head of his cock against her asshole.

Susie whimpered again.

She was impossibly tight, and the broad tip of his cock was not going in.

“Relax,” he murmured.

“I can’t.”

“Think of last night,” he said, stroking the top of her head as if he were petting her. “Remember how good it felt.”

“That was nonconsensual.”

He startled but kept stroking her head. “Well, then…think about the wonderful way you sucked my cock earlier.” He pushed his cock against her ass, but despite the lubrication, there was no give.

“Like I said, it didn’t feel like I had much of a choice,” she hissed.

He chuckled and pressed himself forward with more force. Slowly, her asshole began to yield. Perfect. “Then think about how nonconsensual this is. Hmm?”

The pucker of her ass spread a little more, the tip of his cock began to slide in.

Yes.

“I want you like this,” he growled, gripping her shoulder with one hand as he pushed himself in deeper. “And I know you want it too.”

That was the head of his cock inside her ass. Susie was gasping for air, her body shaking beneath him, and they’d hardly even begun.

Arken kissed the side of her neck tenderly. “Don’t you?”

Susie shook her head, refusing to look his way.

“Tell me you don’t want it, my dear.” He pushed his cock in further, sliding the first inch of his thick shaft past her sphincter.

Fucking perfection.

“Tell me you don’t want me to fuck your ass until you scream.”

Susie shook her head, but the move brought her neck closer to his mouth, her hair tickling his face. It was almost as if she were inviting him to…

“Tell me the bite marks make you feel ashamed,” Arken murmured, sliding his lips along her neck. There were no marks on this side of her neck, and it made his fangs and balls ache. “Tell me you hid them so no one would know what I did to you.”

He heard her gulp, and saw a tear fall, wetting the dry stone beneath her tense fingers.