AllFreeNovel
Share Us
The surreal feeling of the situation began to fade and was replaced by a feeling of contentment. Of satisfaction. I'd been searching for some affirmation of life, and I'd found it between these two men.
And I had to admit – I felt safer than I had in a very long time.
CHAPTER FIFTEEN - BENNETT
Not the evening I had planned for us, but as I stared down at Hailey sleeping soundly beside me, I wasn't sure I regretted a thing. Quinn was sleeping with her with his arm wrapped around her waist as if he was intent on keeping her safe even while they slept. I had the feeling Quinn really cared for her – as did I. But I got the impression that with Quinn, it went deeper than just the sex and he held onto her almost protectively.
I should have felt guilty for fucking her then, but I didn't. And I should have felt incredibly weird that my brother and I had shared her. But I didn't. I'd wanted Hailey since that first time we talked in my truck all those years ago. The quiet, bashful girl who had no idea how beautiful she really was.
At the time, she'd been too young for me. Seeing her again all these years later though, I'd been blown away. She'd grown more beautiful and more confident in herself. Two things that I couldn't deny attracted me to her. I'd honestly only wanted to get to know her better. To see if we connected. And as I looked down at her naked body, all I could think was that apparently, we had. At least on some level.
I heard the front door open and shut downstairs and felt a jolt of adrenaline tear through me. I scrambled quickly to find my pants, waking Quinn up first.
“Shit, are her parents home?” he whispered, his face a mask of fear.
“Yeah, I think so.”
We both pulled on our pants, not even having a moment to talk about how weird this whole situation was. We'd just shared a girl. I had never in my life done anything like that with my brothers. Doing something like that had honestly, never crossed my mind. But something about the situation, in that moment, just felt – right. I couldn't explain it – and didn't have the time to analyze it – but, something in the way everything had unfolded felt natural.
Hailey's eyes fluttered open and saw us getting dressed, and she sat up. A look of hurt crossed through her eyes and I realized that she probably thought we'd gotten our rocks off and were bailing on her.
“What's going on?” she asked, a slight tremor in her voice.
“Your parents,” Quinn said, leaning down to kiss her nose. “They're home.”
Although the hurt melted away, it was replaced with something close to panic. With wide eyes, Hailey hopped from the bed and started scrambling for her bra and shirt. I found the bra, Quinn found the shirt. We tossed both at her at the same time as we heard footsteps coming up the stairs.
Hailey looked at both before tossing the bra under the bed, throwing on her sweater and pulling her leggings up, nearly tripping until I managed to catch her.
“Careful,” I said with a laugh.
When the knock came, we were all three dressed and sitting on her bed again. Everything looked perfectly normal and perfectly innocent. For the most part.
“Hailey?” her mom said.
“Yes?”
“Can I come in, please?”
We all looked at one another and tried not to laugh, Hailey hushed us. It was hard to not think we were back in high school all over again.
“Uhh, sure,” she said. “It's open.”
The door opened, and panic hit me. What if it was obvious – Hailey's hair was a mess, falling loose from her ponytail now, and Quinn had a guilty look on his face. I tried not to meet her mom's eyes at all, feeling like there was no way I could after what we'd done with her daughter – no matter how amazing it felt to us at the time.
Ada Roberts didn't have a good look on her face when she stepped inside. In fact, she looked positively grim, which sent a stab of fear into my heart again. Something had happened – and it wasn't that she'd figured out we'd just had the strangest threesome I'd ever experienced in my life. Something was genuinely wrong.
“Honey, I have some bad news,” she said, sitting on a chair across from the bed. “Leo has already posted bail and has been released. He's already out there somewhere.”
Hailey's face fell. Her hands were clenched in front of her, and although she forced her fists to open, she started wringing her hands.
“Already?” she managed to choke out.
“I'm afraid so,” her mom said. “We can go down to the courthouse and file a restraining order –”
“A restraining order won't do anything,” Hailey scoffed. “Not with someone like him. He laughs at things like that.”
“It's all we can do, Hailey,” her mother said.
