AllFreeNovel
Share Us
“Super hot,” Connor chimed in. “Like fire.”
“So we decided to try it.”
“Uh-huh. This was your first time fucking the same girl?” Seth purposely baited the hook.
“Yeah. Totally,” Connor lied.
“One hundred percent.” Jack nodded.
“Really?” Seth probed them while they nodded like matching bobbleheads. “Then what did you mean when you told Connor to slow down because he fucked too fast every time you let him take the ass?”
Jack blanched. “Shit. You heard that?”
“Oh, I heard everything, including Connor’s ‘once you’ve had twins, you won’t go back’ bullshit.”
His brothers exchanged mirrored expressions of oh, fuck.
“Okay, look,” Connor tried to reason with him. “We’ve taken a few together, but—”
“How many?” Seth asked.
“Why does it matter?” Jack swallowed tightly.
“Because it does. How many? Five, ten, fifty? A hundred?”
“I-I don’t know. W-we kind of…lost count.” Jack winced.
Lost count? Jesus… “How long have you two been sharing girls?”
They exchanged another glance, both gaping and wriggling like worms on a hook.
“Don’t look at each other so you can get your stories straight. I want the fucking truth.”
Jack sighed. “Since ninth grade.”
That sent Seth reeling. Why hadn’t he ever noticed the signs? Clearly, he’d been too wrapped up in his own life, his own problems. His own bullshit. Or maybe he simply hadn’t known what to look for then. Now he did. “How old were you?”
They glanced at one another for confirmation, then answered together. “Fourteen.”
Good god. They’d been two years from having their driver’s licenses and they’d been fucking girls together? “Have either of you ever had sex with a woman alone?”
“I have.” Jack nodded. “For sure.”
“Same,” Connor assured.
“Yeah? How often? And don’t bullshit me, guys. You’re both horrible liars.”
Jack flinched. “Once. With my girlfriend at the time.”
Seth turned to Connor. “And you?”
He shrugged. “Yeah, once. I-I wanted to know what it was like, so…”
“So he pretended to be me, but my girlfriend figured it out.”
“That was a horrible trick to play on her.” Seth sent a thunderous scowl Jack’s way. “And you just let your brother hop in the sack with your girlfriend? Idiot. I hope she broke up with your sorry ass once she figured out you two had deceived her.”
“Actually…” Jack tried to pass off his grimace as a smile. “She didn’t mind. She asked us to do her together and—”
