AllFreeNovel
Share Us
“Have you ever...done anything like that before?” Colton asks.
I shake my head.
“No anal whatsoever?” says Sawyer.
I shake my head again. I wait for them to tell me they won’t do it, that it’s too ambitious, that one of them should fuck my ass first while I blow the other, just to be sure I like it.
But I already know I’ll like it. It’s what I’ve been preparing for, what we’ve been working toward all this time, even if we didn’t know it.
“You’re absolutely sure?” Sawyer says.
“God, yes.” I won’t lie, it is a little scary, and it’ll probably hurt, but the potential fear and pain is barely an afterthought when I catch the smile pulling at Colton’s lips.
“Who’s coming in through the back?” he asks. They’ve both got fat cocks. No matter who it is, it’s going to be a lot to handle.
“Whoever wants it more,” I say.
The men stare each other down for so long, I come close to telling them to rock-paper-scissors for it.
“You do it,” Sawyer says finally. “I’ve been dying to get inside that pussy all night.”
Colton leaves the room, then returns a few seconds later with a bottle of lube. He’s buzzing with anticipation laced with something else, either excitement or anxiety. Probably a mixture of both. I meet his gaze and we share a smile.
“Want to come in from the top or the bottom?” Sawyer asks.
“Top,” Colton says. “She’ll straddle you on the bed, and then then I’ll come in from behind.”
Listening to them negotiate how they’re going to fuck me makes my stomach flutter. Sawyer lies down so I can straddle his hips. He runs his hands over my ass and thighs. I give his cock a few good strokes before I slide down onto him. He groans, his fingers digging into the flesh my hips as my pussy engulfs him.
“Think you can hold off long enough for me to get in there?” Colton asks with a smirk.
“I can hold off longer than you, old man,” Sawyer rasps. “Bet you a week of dishwashing that you’ll blow your load in under five minutes.”
“You’re on, kid.”
I shake my head, chuckling, as I drape myself over Sawyer’s body. I already feel like I’m being impaled with only one cock inside me. I can’t imagine there’s a ton of room leftover, but I’m eager to be proven wrong about that.
Colton smooths lube over my back entrance. I gasp, not used to getting attention there. He tests my asshole with a slickened finger, sliding partway inside.
“Go slow,” Sawyer says. “Make sure she’s good and ready before you try to get in there.”
“I appreciate the pointers,” Colton says, “but this isn’t my first time entering through the backdoor.”
“I don’t care how many backdoors you’ve stepped through. If you hurt this one, I’ll throw you out on your ass.”
“Sawyer, it’s all right.” I kiss his frowning lips. “I asked for this.”
“I know. I just don’t want you to get hurt.” He kisses my forehead. I can’t help the warm, fuzzy feeling I get from Sawyer switching into protective mode. Fortunately, Colton doesn’t appear to be taking his son’s jabs personally.
“Don’t worry,” Colton says. “I’ll take good care of our girl.”
He slides his finger the rest of the way inside me. I sigh, pushing back toward the welcome invasion, and at the same time, taking Sawyer’s cock deeper. He remains still as Colton fingers my asshole. After a few minutes, Colton tries adding a second finger. He has to back off twice when my muscles refuse to accept him, but after some deep breaths, I ask him to try again.
Sawyer rubs my back. I close my eyes and try to focus on my breathing, on being open and relaxed. It takes a while, but eventually I’m taking two, and then three of Colton’s fingers into my ass.
“Ready to try my cock?” Colton asks.
I nod. “Yes.”
