AllFreeNovel
Share Us
He pulls back. My eyes are closed, and my lungs struggle to sustain me. He says, “Please tell me you feel the same way.”
This isn’t how the stepbrother porn I shamelessly watch works out. I pray that James doesn’t remember the time he caught me watching it. On the videos, there’s always some silly setup that’s all about sex. I have too many feelings.
I have to figure out how to handle this. How to move forward. Escape…that’s a nice option. “I tell you what, go sit down, and I’ll grab drinks. And by drinks, I mean water.”
Rushing to the kitchen, I keep my eyes on the ground and hurry past Heath and Ford. I can’t deal with all of the confusing emotions bubbling inside of me like a witch’s cauldron.
I pull cups out of the cabinet then realize I could offer the hot apple cider I planned for myself, but when I turn, Ford is right behind me.
“I’ll get it. Why don’t you have a seat at the bar,” he says.
The bar. That’s a nice way to put the counter that divides the living room from the kitchen. Since my legs are about to give out, I accept his offer. I add the option of mulling spices and apple juice, which everyone agrees to, and he gets to work.
Perhaps Heath doesn’t want to be outdone because he rushes into the kitchen to help.
James walks up behind me, rests his hands on my shoulders, then whispers in my ear. “Remember that time I caught you watching porn?”
So, he does remember.
“It was just—“
“I know your kink.” He puts a finger to my lips to shush me. “I can give you that fantasy.”
Breathe. Stay upright. Refrain from telling him I still shamelessly watch it…and think of the three of them. I’m doing all of the normal life-sustaining things as he spins me sideways on the stool and kneels in front of me.
If I doubt what he’s proposing, his hands resting on top of my knees, his fingers begging for space between my legs, makes it undeniable.
I glance at my brothers across the kitchen. Their backs are to us.
After a single breath of consideration, I decide to believe that we’ve all matured and that I’d be a fool not to go after what I want.
I part my knees.
Three
Jameson
Igambled,andIwon. During the kiss, when Maggie’s lips gave in to me, it became clear the desire wasn’t mine alone. She shares it. The question is if she shares it with all of us, or just me.
The guys and I talked before the auction and decided we’d be willing to have a group thing instead of making her choose. Not exactly magnanimous.
Honestly, it makes sense so that we can be sure she’s taken care of at all times because this isn’t a one-and-done scenario for us. We’re leaving it up to her if she wants one, two, or three of us.
She deserves more than one man can give her. And here I am, crouched under her kitchen counter, hidden from my brothers, about to make my bid for her affection.
They’re asking her questions about where she keeps her spices, and when I look up, her eyes are focused on them. Listening to cabinets opening and closing, and mugs being set down, I wait for her to meet my gaze. My fingers are already tucked into the waistband of her panties.
She gives me a nod and then lifts so I can pull them off. I can barely believe that I’m going to give my stepsister an orgasm. After her comment about being the shy, nerdy, plain girl who never gets asked out, I’m stoked that I could be her first. But I’m troubled that she thinks of herself as shy and plain. She’s anything but.
I’ll give her credit for nerdy though. Those damn glasses, which she’s pushing up her nose as we speak, are part of her hot nerd vibe. How does she not understand that?
I can’t wait to rock this nerdy girl’s world.
Is she focusing on our brothers because they’re looking at her or is she nervous about taking the next step? I rub her outer thighs first. Her skin is so silky smooth I don’t even deserve to be touching someone as perfect as her. I work my way onto the tops of her thighs with several slow strokes and then to her inner thighs. Back and forth, caressing from her knees to her sweet curls.
The scent of her sex already has my mouth watering and my cock hard, but her legs are too close together to get my mouth where it can do its best work.
My thumbs hook between her knees and tug ever so slightly.
