AllFreeNovel
Share Us
“That sounds challenging,” I said. A smile pulled at my lips. “But also fun.”
“That’s the spirit,” I heard one of them say.
“Now finish getting undressed and let me have more clues,” I said with a playful wink.
I pulled at the nearest guy’s belt and he smiled down at me. At the same time, all three of them removed their pants, dropping them down to the floor and showing off matching boxers.
I let out a low groan followed by a chuckle. “Of course your underwear matches too. You guys are pros at this.”
I pulled at the boxers of the nearest guy, sliding my hand down them and gripping his cock in my hands.
“I wonder if you could guess us simply by feeling us,” one of the guys said.
“I highly doubt that but it sounds fun to try.”
I stroked the cock in my hand and stared up into his eyes. It wasn’t his cock that gave him away, it was the grin from earlier and the way he was looking at me. “Hello Jackson.”
“Mmm, you’re good at this,” he said, closing the distance between us and kissing me deeply. “And I don’t just mean at guessing.”
“My turn,” one of the other guys said, and Jackson moved out of the way. My hand slipped from his boxers and under the waistband of the next brother.
Something in the way he looked at me, and the boldness of standing up to his brother made me confident in my guess, but I still wrapped my hands around his thickness and ran my hand up and down a few times for good measure. His eyes darkened, nearly closed, as a look of bliss passed over his face.
“Aiden,” I said, speaking with confidence, giving his cock a firm squeeze and watching the pleasure wash over his face.
“Jackson’s right. You are good,” he said, his voice low and husky. “I don’t want to let you stop but we do have all night together.”
Aiden kissed me before removing my hand from his boxers.
“It wouldn’t be fair if Nate didn’t get a shot. Pretend you don’t know it’s him,” Aiden teased.
“Of course you’re Nathan,” I said as I slipped my hand into his boxers.
I stroked Nathan’s cock a few times as he leaned down and kissed me, his hands in my hair as he held my face against his.
A voice came from behind him. “Do you know what your prize is for getting it right?”
“Mmm, didn’t know there was a prize,” I said as Nate slipped my hands from his boxers. “But I’m eager to find out.”
“Why don’t you just lie back there and let us show you then,” Nate said, gently nudging me onto my back.
“Now close your eyes,” Jackson said.
“Why?” I laughed.
“Because we’re going to move around so you can’t be sure who is who again,” he said with his typical crooked grin.
A shudder ran through me and my body writhed against the bed at the thought of each of them taking turns with me. Trying to guess who was inside of me and not knowing for sure… that idea was beyond anything I’d ever fantasized about and just the thought of it caused the ache inside of me to grow.
I laid back on the bed as the guys removed their boxers. Staring at three identical, hunky men, knowing what they intended to do to me… I had to pinch myself to be sure I wasn’t dreaming.
I knew it was likely the last time we would ever be together like that. Once the New Year hit, we would have to go our separate ways and pretend like nothing ever happened. But that didn’t mean I wasn’t going to enjoy myself one last time.
I closed my eyes as they requested of me, and a second later, hands and mouths began exploring my naked body. Someone nudged my legs apart, and they were kissing my inner thighs. Someone else had a nipple in their mouth, gently sucking and lapping at the sensitive skin. And another mouth found mine and kissed me deeply.
I gave myself over to the pleasure.
“Can I open my eyes?” I whimpered.
