AllFreeNovel
Share Us
I pulled out a stool and sat down across from him, my emotions still swirling. “Caden, what the hell is going on?”
He chuckled and leaned forward, his gaze unwavering. “What do you mean?”
“Connor told me that you two agreed to share me. He fell asleep in my bed. He’s still up there right now,” I blurted out.
“He’s not wrong,” Caden murmured, taking a long draw of his beer before his gaze locked onto mine.
My jaw dropped slightly, a mix of shock and disbelief filling my mind. “You’re telling me that you agreed to share me?”
Caden’s laughter was unbridled, but there was a hint of seriousness in his eyes. “I am. And we meant it. No joke, Anastasia.”
The situation was becoming even more surreal by the second. “Are you both out of your minds? This isn’t something you decide on a whim!”
Caden leaned closer, his voice firm yet tinged with amusement. “Sometimes, life throws you a curveball, and you just have to swing at it. And if it’s a curveball we all seem to like, well, why not?”
I sighed, pinching the bridge of my nose, feeling overwhelmed. “This is insane.”
He nodded, still grinning. “Maybe it is. But sometimes, the craziest things make sense. And let’s face it, you’re something special, Anastasia. We both see that.”
I blushed, the heat encroaching my cheeks enough to overwhelm me. For a moment, words failed me, and my mouth opened and closed.
“I see the way you look at him, sweet girl. He sees the way you look at me. What if, in this case, you could have both of us? Would you like that?”
I met Caden’s gaze, trying to discern if he was being serious or just toying with my emotions. The truth was, I did care deeply for both of them, and the idea of choosing between Connor and Caden was a dilemma I never thought I’d face. I swallowed hard, chewing the inside of my cheek and trying to figure out what the best answer was.
“Don’t think about what I want to hear, Anastasia. You will tell me whatyouwant, or else I’m going to put you to bed with a red-hot bottom,” he threatened, and I could have sworn my cheeks burned even hotter.
“Caden,” I breathed, and his eyes burned into mine with firm intent. With that look, I had no doubt that I would end up over his knee if I didn’t answer him.
“I want to tell you something, Anastasia,” he said, and I stopped short.
“What is it?” I pressed.
“I know you weren’t really contrite after your spanking. If I have to punish you tonight for not answering me, I will make sure you are truly contrite before I put you to bed,” he warned.
“Yes, Caden,” I whispered, my face burning with fire. I knew he meant every word. Even now, my bottom was still slightly sore from his hand, even though it wasn’t pink anymore.
I knew it wasn’t. I’d peeked in the mirror before I’d gone to bed.
“Let me tell you something else, little girl,” he continued, and I squirmed in my chair, his words immediately making me feel small and just the teensiest bit vulnerable.
“What’s that?” I asked.
“I’d love to share you with my brother, little girl, but hear this. Being shared by the two of us will also mean that you’ll be spanked bybothof us whenever you earn it.”
I could have sworn that my face caught flame.
“Bybothof you?” I echoed, swallowing hard as my pussy clenched even harder.
“That’s right, little girl,” he answered.
He took a big swig of his beer, and I chewed my lower lip. The idea of being shared by the two Murphy brothers, as unconventional as it was, filled me with a thrilling mix of excitement and nervous anticipation. This sort of thing only happened in romance novels, and the prospect of experiencing something so incredibly daring and passionate in real life sent shivers down my spine.
“What if I was interested in the two of you sharing me?” I asked before I even realized that I’d spoken aloud. Caden’s piercing blue eyes met mine, searching my gaze for a long moment before his lips turned up in a knowing smile.
“I would tell you that it makes my cock very,veryhard to hear that, babygirl,” he answered, and I couldn’t help but suck in a nervous breath at his words.
“I like that,” I admitted, but my words were hardly loud enough for me to hear, let alone him.
