AllFreeNovel
Share Us
I was so caught up in the feel of her sweet, sweet pussy surrounding me, I forgot for a long moment that I needed to proceed with caution. She’d made it clear she was a virgin. That meant this could hurt, right?
“Just a second,” Tinley said.
I froze. I wouldn’t move again until she gave the go-ahead.
She started moving. They were tiny, barely detectable movements that eased me inside her. It would normally test my struggling self-restraint, but not with Tinley. With her, my top concern was that she was comfortable.
“Ooh,” she finally said. “Yeah, that’s starting to feel good.”
With that, her movements grew bolder. I pulled her toward me a little, putting her clit within reach again. I began stroking as she bounced against me, her ass pounding into my pelvis.
“Oh, God, that feels good,” I said, repeating her words.
It hit me as her hand landed on top of mine on my hip. The next time I made love to her, I wanted to look her in the eye.
The next time I made love to her.
I didn’t just want to do this again. Ineededto do this again. And for the rest of my life. This was the woman for me.
Had the sweetheart muffin actually worked? Or was it just this woman, taking over my mind, body, and soul?
I was in love.
“Yes!” Tinley cried out, pulling me out of my thoughts. “Oh, yes. Just like that.”
As her pussy tightened around me, I felt the last threads of my restraint break.
My movements increased as I drew closer. And closer. And then I was coming, emptying my seed into her. Marking her as my woman, hopefully forever.
And possibly getting her pregnant.
“Oh, shit.”
I pulled out, but it was too late. The damage was done.
Maybe it was my tone. Maybe it was that I’d pulled away from her so suddenly. But when she turned, her hands were over her breasts. She suddenly needed to cover herself?
“What’s wrong?” she asked.
Good question. Should I be honest with her? Yes, I had to. If I’d gotten her pregnant, her life would be completely upended nine months from now. Mine too.
The difference was, I loved the idea that she might be pregnant. Nothing would make me happier.
“I didn’t use protection.” I looked around, remembering the days I carried a condom in my wallet just in case. Not anymore. I’d sworn off impromptu sex with strangers months ago. “I didn’t even think about it.”
“It’s cool.” She squeezed around me and snatched up her clothes. “I’m on birth control.”
That should’ve brought relief, but instead, I felt like I’d been punched in the gut. It had nothing to do with her not getting pregnant. It was her sudden change in…everything.
“Is something wrong?” I asked.
Tinley shook her head but didn’t make eye contact. “I’m fine.”
This was it. This was where she realized she’d made a huge mistake in sleeping with me. It was exactly what I’d tried to avoid.
“You should know something about me,” I said.
Her eyes widened. She froze with her shirt in her hand, seeming to wait for me to finish the thought.
