Page 22 of Pretty Prey

“Hold on, little prey.”

She does just that, gripping my arms for dear life as I slide out and back in with brutal force. She moans in approval. I know she has to be in some pain, but she doesn't seem to mind. If her cries mean anything, she's enjoying this just as much as I am.

“I… I want to see you.”

I wanted to wait until we were done, but the way she begs makes me want to give in, to give her anything and everything she could ever want.

“Ask again, the right way,” I say into her ear as I press my lips to hers, claiming her mouth for the first time.

She tastes like my salty precum and toasted marshmallow. Of course she does. I pull my lips away and still my thrusts.

“Please Sir, I need to see you,” she says.

My fingers make quick work of untying the black silk from her eyes. She has them clenched shut as I resume my thrusts.

“You promise not to freak out?” I say still in a deeper tone, not ready to reveal myself just yet.

“I promise, Sir.”

I kiss her one more time, hoping to extend this veil of mystery just for a couple of seconds longer.

My eyes rake over her body one more time, taking a mental note of every centimeter of her skin, savoring our connection as it is, in case she screams her safe word or something worse, the second I let her open her eyes.

I take in a deep breath as I pump into her, and start burying myself in her heat as far as I possibly can.

“Open your eyes, little prey.”

Her long eyelashes flutter as her eyes adjust to the onslaught of dim light. Then her lips turn up in the corners.

“I knew it was you.”

“Are you happy, little prey?”

“Yes Sir, now fuck me like you mean it.”

His Prey

CHAPTER 27

Part of me always knew it was him, that it had to be Benji. It made the most logical sense. As I wade in the water towards him, seeing him bask in the early morning sunrise feels so surreal. Like, there's no way this man wants me, nor would he go to the lengths he has to keep me safe and cared for.

Back in Maple Brook Falls, he was always around the Rainbow Reading Room and the community center when we were there, lurking like he was a little fly on the wall. But now I see why he didn't know how to show me what he wanted, or if I'd have said yes to his advances. Honestly, I don't know if I would have. Yeah, I had a little crush on him, but it always seemed so wrong. He's my dad's age.

Now that he took my virginity, saved my life, and confessed his feelings for me after he filled me with his cum, I know we're meant for each other. I might love Annie, but she won't be able to come to terms with her own feelings before she runs off to college. Benji will do whatever it takes to stay by my side, and Iknow I'll do the same. He's who I belong with, who sees the real me and doesn't shy away.

“Come here, little prey.”

He pulls me close to his chest, wrapping my legs around his waist below the murky water. I wrap my arms around his shoulders, leaning in for a kiss, something we just can't seem to stop doing.

“I want you to stay with me for a couple more days. I can tow your Jeep behind my truck back home when we get ready to leave. Today's my birthday, and I want to spend it with you.”

“My parents and the girls will ask too many questions.”

I want to say yes, to let us have our time together just being ourselves without any distractions or barriers.

“Let me call Hunter, he'll cover with your dad if I explain everything to him. When we get back to Maple Brook Falls, I'll talk to your parents myself, but little prey you need to decide what you're going to do.”

He is talking about my future because if I leave for college, all of this is for nothing.