At some point, we’re going to have to reexamine our rules. The ones we laid out in the beginning. And probably find new rules for whatever we’re making here.
Finn slides his hand up my bare leg. I turn to meet his mischievous green eyes. He winks at me before reaching for my shorts. Really? Now? Here? I arch an eyebrow and glance over at the others focused on the movie.
Even Dante seems engrossed. Though when I look at him, he glances my way to check on me. When his gaze trails to Finn, he smirks and shakes his head before returning his attention to the screen.
Finn waits for my permission.
Wyatt and Drew don’t even look back at us. We chatted while we ate the pizza. Mostly about the workweek. But once the movie was on, we were all watching intently.
Meeting Finn’s hopeful eyes, I bite my lip and nod. Finn kisses my inner thigh and drags my shorts and panties down my legs.
We don’t have to worry about Tom and Natasha venturing up here. It’s one of the reasons we put the TV in this loft. Besides, even if they came up, they would see the couch back before they’d see me.
But all Drew and Wyatt need to do is turn to see what Finn is doing, but they haven’t. There’s something naughty about being naked and messing around in the living room when not everyone is aware.
Finn parts my thighs and my pussy grows even wetter as he stares at my center. Heat engulfs me, making me restless, needy. I bite my lip to keep from making a sound, wanting him to do something, anything, to relieve this ache building inside. He kisses my thigh again, closer to my pussy. Easing up my body slowly so the others won’t notice.
It’s like we’re getting away with something wicked.
Finn holds my thighs open as he dips his head down and slides his tongue along my pussy. My breath catches as pleasure spirals through me. I’m careful not to make a sound. His wicked eyes lift to meet mine as he settles between my legs. He sucks and licks my clit, pushing me higher and higher with every stroke. My breathing grows frantic as he spears his tongue into my entrance.
I arch my back against Dante.
Grinning, Finn backs away to kiss my thigh. Fuck that.
I grab his hair and bring him back to where I need him most. His low chuckle isn’t loud enough to draw the attention of the others, but it vibrates softly against my clit, pushing me even higher.
Finally, he stops teasing and really begins to work me. My thighs try to clench around him, but he holds them pressed out to the sides. I don’t even know what’s going on on the screen anymore. All I know is I’m about to come and it’s going to be explosive.
My hips rock into his face, riding the waves threatening to drag me under. I clench my fingers in his hair, holding him right in the spot that’s driving me wild. My lips part as fireworks light behind my eyes. A hand covers my mouth to muffle the moan I can’t hold back.
Finn keeps at me even though I’m so sensitive I squirm from him and try to pull his head away, but he resists. He slides his hands up under my ass and cradles me for his torment.
I fly over the edge again, whimpering at how good it feels and needing it to stop in the same breath. Finn lets me lift his head, but he slides three fingers inside me and it shoves me off the edge. I plummet back into myself.
Dante keeps his hand over my mouth. I glance up at him, but his gaze is fixed on Finn’s fingers working in and out of me, pushing me toward another orgasm already.
I shatter and gush around his fingers. Finn’s smirk is wicked as he sits up and drags his boxers down to free his cock.
Without saying a word to each other, Finn grabs hold of my hips, Dante takes my shoulders, and they turn me over until I’m on all fours on the couch. Pleasure spirals through me at these two men needing me. Dante strokes his cock. Precum glistens on the tip. I lift my gaze to his light blue eyes and see the desire in them. When I lower my mouth over his straining cock, Finn thrusts into my aching pussy from behind.
Electricity shimmers through me. Dante’s cock muffles my moan at the exquisite feeling. The others might notice at any point. Turn and see us fucking.
Dante takes my hair and guides me over his cock while Finn fucks me hard from behind, holding my hips steady as his cock shuttles in and out of my pussy. It’s not a secret that we fuck, but there’s something almost forbidden about what we’re doing. I moan around Dante’s cock as another release spirals through me.
The movie gets loud, and Finn and Dante work me hard and fast on their cocks until they both come deep inside me. I swallow Dante’s cum as my pussy milks Finn’s cock with another orgasm. For a second, we just breathe, still connected. Dante lifts my mouth off his cock as Finn eases out of me.
I’m breathing heavy as I lock eyes with Dante. He smirks.
Finn slides my panties and shorts back up my legs to cover me. Then Dante eases me down so I’m lying face down on his chest with my head turned toward the TV. I glance at Wyatt and Drew, but if they heard or saw anything, they ignored it.
I could get used to this.
Finn
When I check on Sara, she’s asleep on top of Dante. I don’t know how the others didn’t realize what was happening. Or they did realize but knew part of what turned Sara on was the thought they didn’t know. That it was our secret.
There’s still a lot we need to discuss about living together and sharing Sara. But it should be done when she’s awake. We stayed up late almost every night this week to finish setting up the house. It meant I didn’t partake in any nightly escapades, knowing Sara needed her sleep.