Page 85 of Badmouths & Bards

“You can tell us,” Casimine encouraged as he genuinely wanted to know.

“I know you’ve both been in the same person at the same time,” Tala licked her lips. “But have you ever been in the same…well, the same hole?”

Casimine’s cock twitched again, a bead of fluid crowning the top at the mental image Tala had provided them.

“Fuck.” Ameriden dropped his head against her shoulder. “You can’t say shit like that.”

“No, please do,” Casimine insisted, leaning toward Tala’s warm face. “I think I like where this is headed.”

“I—shut up,” Tala grumbled. “I was just curious what it would be like, is all.”

“It’s a lot of work,” Ameriden admitted, lifting his head to look at Tala properly. “We would have to go slow and cast a lot of magical slick to make sure you’re really prepared.”

His lover wasn’t wrong given the few times they had attempted the act. Usually, they preferred their cocks finding homes in different areas of their one night stands, but this was different. This was Tala, and Casimine could easily admit he was already willing to do whatever she desired. He wanted to see it, to see her, to see them in every possible position. To be so fully wrapped up in pleasure and the glee of simply being with them.

“Is that something you’d want, Tala?” Casimine asked as he stared into her eyes.

Tala dropped her gaze, once again staring at his cock as she contemplated the task at hand. After all, it was going to be challenging for her to accommodate both of them.

“Yeah,” Tala said after a moment with an affirmative nod. “I do. I can handle it. Tell me what to do.”

It took some maneuvering. Ameriden slipped down until he was on his back. He hummed under his breath and with a wave of his hand, slick suddenly coated his fingers. Ameriden wrapped his cock in it with a groan as Tala watched, eyes dilated as Casimine took her breasts into his hands again.

“We’re going to work on getting your body nice and open,” Casimine said, pressing a kiss against her neck. “Why don’t you start by riding Ameriden? He wants you to, see?”

Tala—like the good girl she was—nodded, clambering over Ameriden’s hips. She took his cock in her hand, causing Ameriden to gasp as she slowly sank down onto him. Tala moaned, hands resting on Ameriden’s chest as she adjusted to the first stretch. Casimine crawled to their side, reaching between the small gap between their groins to find Tala’s clit. She gasped when he stroked a finger over it, hips rising and falling in a rhythm that brought her back to Casimine’s fingers. He was relentless, stroking fast then slow and fast again, never letting Tala find the right spot to rub against. By the time Ameriden started talking, the room was filled with the wet smack of their hips.

“That’s it,” Ameriden encouraged. “Keep going, Tala. Fuck, you look amazing. Keep fucking yourself on me, just like that.”

Casimine nearly cursed at his words, dropping to bite Ameriden’s nipple in retaliation. The man only chuckled, then groaned when Tala suddenly arched, hips grinding against Casimine’s fingers as she reached her peak. A sudden shout, a shaky breath, and suddenly she slumped forward.

“Still hard, Amer?” Casimine questioned as his fingers moved from Tala’s clit.

Tala gasped suddenly, reaching forward to slap Ameriden’s pectoral, “Don’t flex, you asshole.”

“Whoops.” Ameriden grinned. “More slick, Casi?”

Casimine had already called for the spell, warming the magical slick on his fingers. He reached behind Tala, teasing over the seam of her ass while Ameriden grabbed her hips. He tilted her up and forward, giving Casimine a view of Tala’s pussy, Ameriden’s cock still hard and snug inside.

“If anything hurts, tell me,” Casimine said, rubbing a gentle circles with his free hand on the small of her back. “You’ll feel a stretch, a slight burn but it shouldn’t hurt if I’m doing it right.”

“Fuck, just do it already,” Tala ordered.

Casimine leaned forward, making sure to nip the meaty part of her ass with his canines. She cursed him, then Ameriden when he flexed his cock again, before holding still. Casimine slid his finger up Ameriden’s cock and crossed the short distance to Tala’s pussy. Gently, he worked his finger in, pressing against Tala’s insides. He could feel her tense, before breathing and going lax and Casimine praised her. Ameriden kissed her cheek, then her lips as Casimine worked her open more, slipping a second finger into the tight space. She was hot, they both were, and the thought of fitting in there with them was driving Casimine mad with impatience. He wouldn’t let it take over his care for Tala, though, and lazily continued to glide his fingers in and out until he felt her body grow lax again.

“You doing okay?” Casimine asked. “Do you need a moment?”

“I think so,” Tala managed a moment later. “There’s just a lot of pressure.”

“No pain though?” Ameriden asked. “If you’re feeling pain, we stop.”

Tala shook her head against his chest. “No, no pain. I can do more. I’m ready.”

Casimine slowly pulled his fingers free, causing Tala to whine, but Ameriden kissed it away. Ameriden straightened his legs, allowing Casimine to carefully straddle them as he cast another spell and coated his cock with more slick. He caught Ameriden’s eye, an unspoken understanding that if anything were to go wrong they would stop immediately.

“Okay, just breathe, Tala,” Casimine murmured before pressing a kiss to her back. “Once I’m inside, just stay still and I’ll do the rest. We’re less likely to slip out or hurt you this way.”

The first press of his cock against her pussy made them all gasp. It was like the melody of a song Casimine didn’t know they could sing. Tight, hot, and so slick as Casimine managed to slip that first inch inside. Tala was involuntarily flexing and Ameriden’s cock twitched against his in return.