I turned around and was greeted with the perfect view. Teo’s body was perfect, and the way he was leaning against the door frame accentuated the curve of his ass.
“You still wearing the plug?” I had just remembered.
“Maybe.”
He tried to walk to the other side of the tub, but I grabbed his wrist and dragged him into my arms. Reaching down, I felt between his cheeks.
“Someone’s still horny,” Teo said.
“I can’t help it when my boyfriend’s this hot.” My hand slid further down and confirmed my suspicions.
“Find it?”
I gave it a little push, causing Teo to thrust forward.
“Fuck.”
“You like that?” I asked, stepping back to lean against the tub. But Teo didn’t need to answer because his dick was doing it for him.
“What do you think?” He grabbed the hardening shaft and made it bounce. “Excited for the real thing. How long are you gonna make me wait for it?” He asked, sliding into the water. “Oh, that feels good.”
“I doubt it will be that much longer, and I’m sorry for being weird about it.” As soon as I joined him in the tub, he scooted over and pushed in between my legs. I wrapped my arms around him and he laid his head on my chest.
“It’s not weird. I’m horny as fuck, but I get it. I’m nervous too, but it’s not like you’re gonna just slam it in there. You’ll be gentle and it will be amazing. We’ll know when the time is right.”
I was worried I was waiting too long, but it seemed Teo was okay with it. To be honest, I didn’t think he’d have to wait much longer. Knowing my cock could be buried inside that tight hole like the gemstone buttplug was an enormous tease.
“You’re hard,” Teo said matter-of-factly.
“Yup.”
“I love that I do that for you. Thinking of how many times you must’ve been hard because of me before–and I didn’t even know it–is incredibly arousing.”
I chuckled. “You make it sound like I’m a stalker.” My fingers were lightly tracing the muscles of his shoulders.
“Well, it’s kind of true, isn’t it?”
When I hesitated to answer, Teo grabbed my hand and made it touch his dick.
“It’s not like I have a problem with it. I actually really like it.”
“That’s…good.” I swallowed. It wasn’t like he was trying to seduce me, but this conversation was making me want to bend him over the side of the tub and and fuck him. “To be blunt, I’m shocked you never noticed me checking out your ass. I’ve been staring at it ever since your team got those new shorts.”
Teo laughed. “The super short ones? From our freshman year? Oh my God, so many guys hated those. They complained their balls were gonna fall out and they all started wearing lycra underneath.”
“I know,” I admitted. “And I’m very glad you weren’t one of them. Your legs looked phenomenal and your butt looked even better.”
“Is that when you started coming to all my games?”
“Maybe,” I teased. “But yes, I jacked off many times thinking about what was underneath.”
“If we keep talking about this, I’m gonna be the one that needs to jack off.”
“Oh yeah?” I gave his dick a squeeze.
“Fuck, I’m serious.”
I nipped his ear. “We didn’t get it all out of you last night?”