Page 34 of Enter if you Dare: Part Three

I told myself I would be calm when he finally returned, that I would hold myself together, but I lied. Tears roll down my cheeks as Cave crosses the shed and wraps his arms around me. He pulls me against his chest as I press my face into him and let myself feel this moment.

His arms tighten around me, and he lifts my feet off the ground. “Mine,” he whispers.

“I love you so much,” I whisper back, and Cave freezes.

“Love,” he repeats. “You.”

Cave sets me back down and looks around the shed; nothing has changed. But then he spots the mini scarecrow above Cipher’s workbench and walks over to it. He takes it down from its spot and smiles before putting it back.

Cipher moves in closer, then picks up the music box and hands it to Cave. “It’s done,” Cipher tells him.

“Come sit,” Noa says. “I think all the adrenaline is wearing off and my legs feel weird.”

We move to the L-shaped sofa, which barely fits us all. Cave sits beside Noa, I sit on Cave’s other side, and Cipher takes the arm.

I don’t know how much time passes before I turn and face Cave to find him already looking at me. He tucks a strand of hair behind my ear, and his hand cups my face.

“Welcome home,” Noa says.

Cave turns his head to look at Noa, and a moment passes between them. Then he does the same with Cipher before he turns back to me. He reaches out and takes my hand, pulling me onto his lap. His forehead comes down to rest against mine, and I close my eyes.

The couch dips beside us, and Cave’s hand grips my waist.

“I like where this is going,” Noa says, and I open my eyes to see Cave smile.

His hands move to the hem of my jumper, and he looks me in the eye, asking for permission. I lift my arms, and he takes his time pulling the material over my head before gripping my waist, encouraging me to stand. Next, he hooks his fingers into my sweats and drags them down, along with my underwear, until everything reaches my ankles, and I step out of the puddle of fabric. He stares at me for a moment, eyes roaming over my body.

“Cave, you good?” Noa asks.

Cave nods in response.

Cipher moves in closer to Cave as he pulls me back onto his lap. Cave reaches out, slipping his hand into Cipher’s jeans, so I lean sideways and undo the button, giving him more access. Cave pulls out Cipher’s cock, then he does the same to Noa.

“Oh shit!” Noa exclaims.

“Mine,” Cave says.

“Oh god, y-yours,” Noa stammers. “Always fucking yours, you nightmare of a man.”

Cave silently laughs, moving his hands slowly, while I reach down and slip my hand beneath his sweats, releasing his hard cock and maneuvering myself above it.

“Is this okay?” I ask, and he nods.

Then he bucks up, the tip of his cock pushing inside me as I sink down, taking every inch of him. He makes a noise deep in his chest when I set the pace, keeping his eyes locked on mine as his hands move in time with our rhythm. All of us are connected to him at this moment. Noa rambles on about this being the best Christmas ever, and though I laugh, I have to agree. Our families are here and Cave is home.

Cipher presses his palm against the side of my face, and I turn to him. He mouths, “I love you,” and I do the same. Cave’s pace changes when mine does; he’s still following my lead.

“Cave,” Cipher whispers, drawing our Scarecrow’s gaze his way. Cipher makes a small sound, and he comes into Cave’s palm.

I slow, knowing my orgasm is close, and wrap my hand around Cave’s wrist, bringing his hand to my mouth so I can lick the cum from his fingers.

“Fuck, that’s hot,” Noa groans out. “Squeeze me harder . . . Yes, just like that. Fuck!”

Noa comes hard, his body jerking as cum squirts into Cave’s hand. Noa’s eyes find mine, and I do the same as with Cipher. I take Cave’s wrist and bring his hand to my mouth, licking the cum from his skin while keeping my eyes fixed on Noa’s, who then pushes up enough to wrap his hand in my hair and bring me closer to him, smashing his lips to mine.

Cave grabs my waist and keeps moving, while Noa deepens the kiss. His fingers touch my clit and circle insistently until my orgasm erupts. My whole body trembles fiercely, though my scream is muffled by Noa’s lips.

Noa pulls back, and I slump against Cave, who wraps me in his arms.