Page 92 of Their Wicked Secrets: Untouched, Vol 5 of 6

“Stay here, kitten.” Eli walks around to the nightstand and grabs a bottle of lube and a dildo with a base out of the drawer.

I swallow, not knowing what’s going to happen next. He sets the dildo next to Jack’s legs. He lifts me and sets me down to straddle Jack’s thighs. I brace my hands on his ass for a second and Jack moans as I press on his sensitive skin.

I pull my hand back, almost saying sorry out loud.

“He likes it, kitten.”

I glance over my shoulder at Eli. Eli smirks and grabs my hand. He rubs lube over my fingers. I can’t question him right now. Not without permission. I watch him do the same to his fingers.

“I’m going to prep your ass, so when Jack’s ready to unload, he can fuck it.” Eli tips my chin up so our eyes meet. His brown eyes are dark abysses, so different from the lightness of Jack’s. “You need to prep Jack’s ass so you can fuck his ass with the dildo, kitten.”

My mouth opens and closes. My pussy pulses just thinking about it. The thought of me fucking in and out of Jack’s ass until he comes. Fuck, I want to do that.

I turn to face Jack’s butt and spread his cheeks to see his asshole. I’ve been prepped many times, especially by Jack, but I’ve never had my fingers inside an ass before. My fingers are slick with the thick lube.

“If you need to stop⁠—”

I shake my head, cutting Eli off. No, I can do this. I want to do this.

If it were just me and Jack, he would walk me through it. He would tell me where to push and when to do everything. He’d let me explore. But this is Eli’s show.

I slide my wet fingers over Jack’s puckered hole. He clenches beneath my touch and lets out a breath, turning his head to the side so I can see his face. His eyes are closed, but his face is flushed with desire.

Pushing the tip of my finger into his asshole, I’m surprised at how tight it is. I push a little deeper feeling him squeeze around my finger before sliding back out. I glance over my shoulder at Eli.

“You’re doing good, kitten. Slide your finger in again.” Eli’s finger glides over my asshole as I press into Jack’s again.

Jack’s face is beautiful in pleasure as I press in and feel the muscles relax around my finger.

Eli sinks his finger inside my ass, and a low moan works out of me. Jack’s ass tightens.

“Follow what I do, kitten.” Eli draws his finger out before sliding it back inside. My insides are on fire.

Jack’s lips part as I do the same to him.

“That’s it, kitten. We’ll have you fucking that ass in no time.”

Fuck. I’m so turned on right now. As Eli works his way up to fucking my ass with one finger, I do the same to Jack, mesmerized by studying his expressions, shifting ever so slightly to hit the spots he seems to like.

“Add another finger, kitten.” Eli draws out before pressing in two. I slide my finger out and then sink two into Jack’s ass. The pressure around my fingers is weird and not like fingerfucking my pussy at all.

“Another, kitten.” Eli sinks another into my ass, stretching me. When I do the same to Jack, the look of ecstasy on his face and the stimulation is enough to push me over the edge. I cry out softly, unable to stop the noise entirely.

“You like fucking Jack’s ass, kitten?” Eli whispers against my ear as he fucks me through my orgasm. His other hand grabs my breast and pinches my nipple. “Answer me.”

“Yes, sir.”

Jack groans.

“I think Jack likes it too.” Eli thrusts his fingers in deep. “Fuck his ass with your fingers until he comes.”

I start slow, drawing my fingers out before thrusting back in, the way the guys do that drives me insane. Jack parts his lips as his hips move with my fingers. It’s erotic to watch him in the throes of his pleasure, knowing I’m the one controlling it.

“Take hold of his balls, kitten.” Eli’s words are dark in my ear.

I do as he says and Jack bucks and lets out a whimper. I fuck his ass harder with my fingers, wishing I could go as deep as the guys do. Suddenly, his ass tightens around my fingers, locking them in place as he moans, deep and guttural.

Eli pinches my nipple and an aftershock floods me. “Good girl. Such pretty little playthings I have.”