Page 69 of Pucking Good Girl

“Really?” She nibbles on her bottom lip, like she always does when she isn’t sure about sharing her thoughts.

“Really. If there’s something else you want to try, I’m game.”

There’s still a moment of hesitation. Talia’s eyes drift from me to Mack and then come back.

She’s still chewing on her bottom lip, and now I’m curious. “There is nothing you can say that will shock me.”

Talia looks at my brother again before setting her gaze back on me. “So you know how Macklin has been helping me try things in bed?”

I stifle an eye roll. “Yeah.” Teaching Talia how to be more confident in bed sounds like anything but a sacrifice.

“There have been a few times when we did some butt stuff.”

“What?” Air goes down the wrong pipe, and I cough out my question, trying not to choke. “You did⁠—”

Mack chuckles, clearly amused by my reaction. I’ve never wanted to smack someone more than I do him right now.

“We didn’t. I didn’t fuck her there.” He clarifies, still way too amused by my glare for my own liking.

“No, we didn’t get to that yet,” Talia says. “It was just a finger, or two. But it felt…”

She’s searching for the right words.

“Good?” I offer.

“Kinda. It was different, but I didn’t hate it. I think it felt better when Macklin was also inside me.”

Is she saying what I think she’s saying? “You liked the feeling of being filled in both places?”

“I did. And I’ve been thinking that if we were ever together again, the three of us, I mean, it would have been interesting to try it.”

It’s Mack’s turn to be confused. “You want us to fuck you together? One in your pussy and the other one in your perfect little ass?”

“I think it would feel really good.”

My cock is in complete agreement. It pulses with need as I picture it. It takes just a quick look at Mack to see that he has my same reaction to Talia’s words.

There’s a beat of silence, and Talia is the one who breaks it, eventually. “Is that something you guys would want to try?”

Yes. No. Fuck. I don’t know.

I mean, yes. It’s so hot that my balls tingle at just the thought of it. But can I share Talia with Mack in that way?

The night of the last party at the Gamma House comes to mind. Sharing Talia then was one of the hottest things I’ve experienced. And we just did it again a few minutes ago. Sure, neither of us was technically fucking her, but I watched Mack come down Talia’s throat while I ate her out. Was I jealous? Maybe a little, but I would be a hypocrite if I didn’t admit that jealousy was only one percent of the emotions I felt.

“I want to try it if you want to.” Mack says.

Fuck. That makes it up to me. But I meant what I said earlier.

“I’ll try whatever you want, pretty girl.”

“Do you know how you want this to go down?” My brother asks.

Mack’s eyes go from Talia to me, and I nod. Like our first night together, he’s letting her call the shots. That’s what makes me feel comfortable with whatever is going to happen next.

As long as Talia wants it, I want it too.

“I was thinking that we could try something similar to reverse cowgirl so you Macklin could face me and you Becks could be behind me.”