Page 186

No, I want to come. I need to come.

What kind of punishment is putting on clothes anyway? Fuck it. Right as I’m about to stop resisting, the fingers disappear. I release a whimper, knowing what comes next and it won’t be me. Someone takes hold of my hair, and I part my lips.

This time I’m going to figure it out, or I’m going to come on someone’s face and get some clothes. Cocks thrust into me at the same time before pulling out. I drag my tongue along the underside of the cock in my mouth, trying to capture some clue. Nico and Jack had their cocks in me before the game so they might have the taste of me still on them.

Before I can think any harder, I’m tugged down onto a mouth. Definitely Jack beneath me. His tongue splits my folds before diving into my soaking entrance.

“Thoughts, kitten?”

“Caden in my pussy.” That one was easy. He’s always more than anyone else.

“And?” Eli asks.

I try to focus as Jack tongue fucks my pussy. “Oh. Fuck. Luke in my mouth.”

“Very nice,” Eli says. “You can finish her.”

Luke grabs my hair again and presses his cock into my mouth while Caden lifts my hips slightly. As Jack continues to suck on my clit, Caden slams his thick cock into my pussy, and I’m gone. My orgasm spirals me out before I fall back into them fucking me, keeping me wound tight as they fuck me properly.

Jack sucks harder, and I can’t stop from coming again, moaning around Luke’s cock as my pussy squeezes around Caden’s. They both groan as they finish inside me.

Luke lifts me up until our mouths collide. Caden pulls out and swats my ass. Jack pushes his fingers through Caden’s cum leaking down my thigh and shoves it back inside me. I tremble in Luke’s arms as Jack finger fucks me until I come again.

I pull the blindfold off as Luke backs away. I glance at Eli, and he gives me a nod like I need his permission to do what I want. They all know I like them ordering me around. I turn around so my ass is toward Nico and bend over Jack to take his cock into my mouth.

Nico grabs my hips and surges forward into my pussy. I moan around Jack’s cock as I work his cock in rhythm with Nico fucking me. Games are fun, but I don’t need one to fuck my guys anymore. Jack traces my nipples with his fingertips and cups my breasts while he watches Nico fuck me.

“I love watching you get fucked, sweetheart.” He kisses my trembling thigh. “Especially while you suck my cock.”

Nico rubs his wet thumb against my asshole before pressing it inside. My release overwhelms me, making me suck harder on Jack and pushing him over the edge. He scoots down beneath me as Nico continues to fuck me. Jack pulls my head down into an upside-down kiss.

I shake as I come around Nico’s cock again while tasting myself on Jack’s tongue. Nico roars his release before he pulls away. Another cock thrusts inside me.

“Eli,” I groan into Jack’s mouth.

Jack smirks against my lips before opening his mouth against mine again. His kiss is deep and erotic while Eli pounds into me, spreading my ass cheeks to stare at my puckered hole while he fucks me hard.

I cry out into Jack’s mouth as my release barrels through me. If Eli wasn’t holding my hips, I would have collapsed, but my guys have me. They always have me.

There are these soft moments that I can’t wait for. I crave them almost as much as I crave a good fuck. It’s late at night. The city lights cast a gentle glow in the room. I’m sprawled over Nico’s chest, and he trails the backs of his fingers lightly up and down my spine.

Caden lies next to me, while Jack, Eli, and Luke are nearby. We went out and explored the city after a hot shower. They fed me and showed me everything Boston had to offer us. We ate lobster rolls and talked about our future. The whole amazing day was spent holding hands with the men I love.

Did I get some looks when I held Luke’s hand but kissed Eli? Some, but what we are is nobody’s business but ours. It might not be easy going to college and being in a relationship with five guys, but I wouldn’t have it any other way.

And to have this? These quiet moments, alone in a bed with my five guys, completely spent and feeling so loved that my heart wants to explode into confetti, make all of this worth it. I can’t wait to spend the rest of my life in their arms.

Coming back to school after the holiday weekend was kind of a letdown. Boston and New York were amazing. We saw so many colleges and places and people. I spent last night on the phone with Kenz telling her all about it while Luke lay with his head in my lap, reading his history text as I played with his hair.

Third period has become my favorite time during the school day. Art has always been my favorite class, but working with Caden on my art projects is epic. Our first one got rave reviews from Ms. Sullivan. It was due shortly after Homecoming, but she gave us all an extension. After that, for the next few projects, she mixed up the rest of the class and changed partners, but not us.

She kept Caden and me together as partners. I can’t begin to describe how it feels to work with him. We both have different styles, but it’s easy to combine them. I did mention to Caden that I could work with Nico or Kenz now, but he wasn’t having it. For art, he wanted to keep me all to himself.

Ms. Sullivan walks over to our desk. “How’s it coming along?”

Caden has his hand on my knee under the table with his thumb brushing lightly over my inner thigh, but he doesn’t remove it, even though our teacher is right here.

“We’ve been working on making sure the colors blend and aren’t too harsh.” Honestly, I love it. It’s a little piece of him mixed with a little piece of me.