AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

Shut Your Mouth

Page 43

by Torrie Robles

I pause at the door, my hand trembling as I fit the key into the lock. The click echoes out into the stillness, a sound that makes my shoulders tighten. When the door swings open, the air inside hits me first, sour and stale, heavy in a way that has nothing to do with dust. I know that smell. Old blood.

Inside, the house feels like a mausoleum, untouched, sealed in silence. Dust drapes across the surfaces like a shroud, softening the edges of what was once immaculate. The living room remains exactly as I remember it, preserved in quiet opulence: the sleek, high-end sofa still firm and sculpted, its fabric dulled only by the thick film of time. The Persian rug beneath lies flat, the pattern buried under years of undisturbed grime. Even the air feels wrong, too still, too dry, like it’s been holding its breath since the day I left.

And yet… nothing is out of place.

The row of photographs on the mantel stands perfectly aligned, untouched by time or guilt. My gaze catches on one in particular, my mother. Her smile beams from behind the dusty glass, bright, captured in a moment that never matched her real life. It stops me cold.

She shouldn’t be here.

He left it up. He meant to. Not as a memorial, he’s not capable of that, but as a message. As if to say she still belongs to him. As if to say I do too. My jaw tightens as I reach out and brush a thumb over the glass. The dust smears, but her face remains. Frozen. Trapped. Just like we were.

I feel it again, that gnawing tension in my ribs, the memory of a house that never felt like home. The silence presses in thick and heavy, layered with everything unsaid.

My chest tightens as I drag in a shaky inhale. Every step forward feels like walking onto a battlefield, my body tensed, my skin prickling with a restless, crawling unease I can’t shake.

In the kitchen, everything looks untouched, a shrine preserved in silence. The counters dull beneath a thin layer of dust, the stainless-steel fixtures dulled only slightly with time. It’s as if someone pressed pause seven years ago, and the room has been holding its breath ever since.

I trail my fingers across the surface. It’s cold and smooth, free of clutter, just as my father always demanded. No dirty dishes. No crumbs. No signs of life.

I can still picture her here, my mother, at this very counter. Not standing proud but shrinking smaller by the day. Her hands, always busy. Her humming, soft and almost apologetic. A tune without words. A melody I’ve never been able to place. Like it was something only she could hear, her last defense against unraveling.

The fridge hums in the background, empty now, like everything else in this house. My gaze catches on a faint shadow in the wood grain by the stove. Barely visible. But I know it’s there. Coffee, spilled on a morning her hands wouldn’t stop shaking. His voice had cut through the walls, sharp, punishing, telling her she wasn’t Godly enough, submissive enough. She’d dropped the towel. Knocked the sugar bowl. Her silence louder than any cry for help.

A breeze rattles the windows, snapping me out of the memory. I glance toward the movement outside, half expecting to see someone standing at the glass. Watching. But it’s just the trees. Just the wind. Just ghosts.

Still, my fingers tighten on the counter’s edge as if holding it could keep me grounded. I can almost hear her voice whispering in my ear, not a song this time, but a warning, quiet, urgent, meant for me alone.

“Be careful, Lydia. Not everyone who smiles is kind. Some of them have teeth beneath their grins.”

And she would know.

Then, as though drawn by invisible strings, I make my way toward the cellar door.

I freeze at the edge of the kitchen, dread pooling low in my gut like something spoiled. The door looms ahead, plain, wooden, and silent, but to me, it breathes. It watches. It waits. My hand trembles as I reach for the knob. The cool metal bites against my palm, and I pause, pressing my forehead to the frame. Just wood. Just hinges.

But my heart doesn’t believe that.

I twist the handle and pull. The creak of the door stretches through the kitchen like a warning. Blackness greets me, thick and pressing, like a living thing. My throat tightens. My lungs forget how to breathe.

I flick the switch, and the single bulb at the top of the stairs stutters to life, casting a sickly yellow light. It flickers like a failing heartbeat, revealing cobwebs that cling to the chain and drift across the ceiling, reaching like fingers toward the walls.

I hesitate. My knees feel waterlogged. Every instinct in my body screams to turn back, to slam the door, to pretend this part of the house doesn’t exist. But I move anyway, my feet heavy, like I’m wading through something thick and unseen.

The railing is cold, the worn wood pressing grooves into my fingers as I grip it. I descend slowly, each step creaking under my weight. My legs shake. My stomach churns. The scent down here hasn’t changed, a damp, musty rot laced with rust.

Halfway down, I gag, quick and sharp, a reflex I barely contain. My vision blurs. My skin prickles with a cold sweat. I brace myself on the wall, grounding against the textured drywall just long enough to keep from collapsing.

It’s just a cellar.

Just a room.

Just a memory.

At the bottom, I stop. My breath comes in shallow bursts. The walls close in, and the silence is deafening. Shelves line the room, canned goods, boxes labeled in his sharp handwriting. Everything still in its place, like time never dared to touch it.

But my gaze drifts to the far wall. The one that divides this cellar from the room where it happened. And suddenly, I’m cold all over.

I reach out with shaking fingers, brushing the drywall. It’s just texture. Paint and plaster. But it hits me like a slap. My knees buckle slightly. My vision dims around the edges.