AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

Magdalene Cruthers Is Going To Hell

Page 14

by Ali Lockhart

“Oh, God, Bridge,” Tom’s thin voice carried down the hall, and, mortification overtaking any fear of a mythical horror lurking in noncorporeal form, Maggie fled to her room.

Maggie expected the Sunday service to be somewhat better attended than a mere dozen people, all subdued. Bridgers called this foray “blending in,” which seemed to Maggie to be a fairly hypocritical stance from a man who had insisted that they were safe from any recognition in Minnesota. Perhaps he thought that no one would suspect God-fearing citizens of having scammed sad people out of money for a decade. But as usual, her protests had fallen onto two pairs of deaf ears and here they were, in the fifth row, left pew, watching Reverend Samuel Myerson recite his sermon. Maggie dropped her eyes to the hymnal on her lap, the words as unfamiliar to her as ancient Greek, and she snuck a side-glance at her brothers. Bridgers, so far, had done an admirable job of appearing to pay attention, nodding vigorously at the right times and looking solemn at others. Tom, seated on Maggie’s opposite side, was less enthusiastic.

He sat quietly, his book of hymns also open on his thighs, eyes fixed on Reverend Myerson with poorly concealed contempt. She nudged his knee with hers and gave him a bracing smile, which he returned grimly. She knew churches dredged up painful memories for him; his family had been nearly fanatical in their religious beliefs, and when he had been discovered kissing another boy at age seventeen, he had been unceremoniously exiled. She resented Bridgers for dragging him here, but when she had asked Tom why he agreed to come, he shrugged. “Whatever Bridge wants,” he had said, half affection, half resignation.

“Casting aside the simplicity of obeying the commandments, we can easily delve into the Word to provide context for why this is such a grave act.” Reverend Myerson looked up from his notes, sending his thin congregation a knowing smile. “I will not insult your intelligence by examining the well-known texts, but I will strive to make them more accessible. To wit, deceit is an offense to not only God, but to oneself.”

Maggie felt a sharp twinge in her spine and shifted in her seat, ignoring the heads turning to look at her movement.

“It could be argued that there is room for falsehoods, that knowing the situation is always required before a judgement is made.” Reverend Myerson paused, his expression turning aggrieved. “This is an opinion that I do not share. Spreading lies is expressly forbidden by God, whom I would not wish to split hairs with.” He flashed another smile and Maggie felt one eyebrow creep up. The reverend was trying to make a joke, it seemed; unfortunately, it appeared to be about the possibility of eternal damnation, so some of the humor was lost in translation.

Maggie spent the remainder of the service trying to look engaged while entertaining herself with thoughts of being quite literally anywhere else. This was unnecessary and frankly intolerable, and she would inform Bridgers at the first opportunity. Tom broke her reverie with a tap to the shoulder and she looked up, startled.

“It’s over,” he muttered, standing and slipping the hymnal back into its slot on the pew in front of him. Maggie followed suit and trailed after Bridgers as he exited the pew on bouncing feet.

Well. She was glad at least one of them had enjoyed themself.

Reverend Myerson was stoically greeting his few parishioners, nodding as he held their hands in his, his mouth thinning as they unburdened themselves.

Maggie recognized a fellow performer when she saw one. His expressions were too precise; they lacked the nuance of genuine emotion. From the first, he had made her uneasy, and that feeling was only growing. “Do we really need to interact with him?” she hissed to Bridgers, wondering again why he was in charge of this endeavor.

“We can’t hide in the store forever,” he murmured, not taking his eyes off his target. “This is a small community, and we would be foolish to try to avoid it. Ah, Reverend!” He greeted the man jovially, taking his outstretched hand in both of his and pumping vigorously. “What a wonderful sermon. Were I given to deception, I would seriously rethink my stance.”

Myerson had the sense to look momentarily stunned before regaining his footing. “I’m so glad you found some value in it, indeed. Pardon, but your face is new to me.”

“Yes, yes, just moved into the old Jensen spot, you know.” The pastor flicked his gaze between Bridgers’ face and his imprisoned hand as her brother continued. “Bridgers Cruthers, at your service. This is my sister, Magdalene Cruthers, and our brother, Thomas Cruthers.”

The pastor withdrew his hand—more of a sharp yank—and wiped his palm on his robe. “Yes, I did meet Magdalene several days ago.” He smiled stiffly at her. “A pleasure to see you again, Miss Cruthers. Mr. Cruthers,” he added, nodding at Tom. Tom nodded back once, his hand firm on the small of Maggie’s back. Tension pulsed through him, and she wished she could give him a cup of tea and a hug. “I already told your sister this,” the reverend continued, “but I would be happy to give you all a tour of the village.”

“Maggie told us that you two had met,” Bridgers replied, his hands now clasped behind his back. Myerson’s mouth twitched. “I’m sorry my brother and I couldn’t be there. Starting up a business is terribly time-consuming, you know. You must have some advice for us! Being so chummy with the Lord and all.”

Tom made a sound next to Maggie, exasperation without much affection woven through.

“Come, the reverend has other people to greet.” He pulled on the back of Bridgers’ jacket. “Thank you for the service, Reverend,” he added, steering the smaller man away from Myerson and towards the dirt path that led to the street. Maggie shot the reverend a smile and followed Tom, lifting her skirts slightly to avoid brushing the mud patches along the road. A prickle touched the back of her neck, and she turned her head sharply to find a large, churlish-looking man staring at her, arms crossed and brow furrowed, his mouth set in a grim line. She normally would have felt taken aback, even frightened, by such an imposing figure, but she only felt a jolt of familiar warmth.

He had the exact same blue eyes as Theo.

Sometimes Minnesota in early June was a sauna. Theo had been to a sauna once as a child when his grandmother had the notion to strengthen familial bonds by sitting naked in a sweaty room while hitting each other with sticks, so he knew of what he spoke. The wet spring was now melting into a wet summer, the air thick enough to feel like an obstacle to walk through. Emmy, who seemed destined to take after her aunt in emotional expression and its lack of nuance, made her opinion known: Every time she was taken into the dull, muggy sunshine, she wailed pathetically into Theo’s chest, her little arms flailing dramatically as she tossed her head from side to side, before finally collapsing into a floppy mass in her father’s arms.

She had just exhausted herself when Theo turned down the street where Mr. Thurson’s paper mill sat. The building squatted next to a small pond that featured a pair of picturesque swans that floated gracefully along the water but would happily attack you if you wandered too near. He shifted Emmy to his other hip to widen the distance between her and the murder-birds as he approached Thurson’s door. Typically he wouldn’t have brought Emmy with him on a work errand, but Mrs. Thurson was utterly taken with her; he figured it was both good business sense to please the wife of his paper supplier and a neighborly gesture to bring someone some joy.

“Barrow!” Ned Thurson belted from his yard, waving. He leaned on a rusty rake, the earth around him half-tilled. Theo smiled as he approached, drawing a deep breath of mingling scents—the stink of the pond, the richness of the freshly-turned dirt, the sweetness of his daughter nestled into him. “We weren’t expecting you or I would have asked Janey to put on some coffee. Hello, my little currant pie,” he crooned at Emmy. Emmy, recognizing a sympathetic tone when she heard one, peeled her face away from her father and reached out to Ned, who laughed as he took her and perched her on his hip. “Janey! Your friend is here!”

Mrs. Thurson appeared in the doorway, squinting, and immediately swept the baby away, cooing as she plopped Emmy on the ground and guided her into the house. “She’s going to help me roll out dough!” she shouted over her shoulder as she disappeared, holding Emmy’s hand.

Ned blinked. “I hope you don’t mind the odd child-napping here and there, my friend.”

“Not if she can make herself useful in the kitchen, certainly.”

Ned’s laugh was a sharp bark. “What can I do for you, Theo? All is well, I hope?”

“As well as can be, Ned, thank you. It’s a boring errand, I’m afraid; we find ourselves in need of more butcher wrap. Don’t suppose you could put in an order from the big man for me?” The small mill, powered only by Thurson and a donkey named Richard, primarily produced small batches of custom papers for stationery shops in St. Cloud and Minneapolis. The overpriced sheets kept the Thursons well-flush, but the large-scale mill, a frightening behemoth of a thing run by Ned’s uncle Cornelius, was upriver, not far from the Barrow butcher house. Most of the paper wraps for the city of St. Cloud and surrounding villages came from there.

“Sure enough, sure enough. I’ll send word along. Should be ready by Friday; he’s quick to work.” Ned paused, fiddling with the rake handle. “Say, Theo, d’you know the new neighbors? Moved into the old studio?”

Theo’s heart gave an extra thump. “I believe so. Brothers and a sister?”

Ned nodded, tapping his chin thoughtfully. “Met the oldest brother. Came in asking about pamphlets.”