AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

Magdalene Cruthers Is Going To Hell

Page 17

by Ali Lockhart

Maggie had been dreading this since she had seen Theo at that counter, smiling and warm, so the punch of nausea, while not unexpected, was still unwelcome. Her fantastical dream of being his friend—of being anything to him, really—had encountered a knife wound at the hands of this cruel, petty woman whom Theo loved. All the scenarios she had run through in her head, from begging ignorance to haughty indignation, fell flat; she had no recourse but to improvise.

“I am sorry that you feel that way.” She raised her stone-cold cup of tea and took a sip. It somehow tasted like wet sawdust. “I do not lie and if you have a particular instance in mind that you would like to discuss civilly, I am all ears.” She did lie, of course. She was lying at that moment by insisting she didn’t lie, which at least made her consistent.

“My God, you cannot help yourself, can you?” Louise snapped. “You looked my brother in the eye and claimed to speak for Sarah. You preyed upon a vulnerable man, and I am certain you have preyed upon many, many others. How you sleep at night baffles me. I find you vile, Miss Cruthers, and if I can accomplish nothing else on this earth, I hope I can convince you and your horrible family to leave Roslyn and never speak to my brother again.”

“I’m sorry the tea is not to your liking,” Maggie replied calmly.

Louise blinked, taken aback. “Pardon?”

Maggie nodded towards the cup clutched in Louise’s hand. “The tea. I didn’t realize you preferred coffee.”

Louise’s eyes dropped to the cup. “Tea is fine. Tea … How do you know I prefer coffee?”

It had been a guess, but most of Maggie’s work had been educated guesses: Louise had scrunched her nose when she had seen the tea tray and had steadfastly ignored the offered drink until her outburst. Her gulps had been followed by a wince, and Maggie threw caution to the wind.

It didn’t always land, but it appeared to have done so this time.

Maggie shrugged. “Whatever I say will be dismissed as a lie, so I do not see a point in discussing it. You are a guest in my home, despite the poisonous abuse you just lobbed at me, and I have a social obligation to make you as comfortable as possible. The least I could have done is offer you the appropriate drink.” She took another sip. “As for your question, no, I cannot help myself. I am who I am, Miss Barrow, and I am sorry if that offends you. I do not prey on anyone, as I am not a large African cat or venomous spider. I provide a service, even if you do not agree.” She eyed Louise, whose mouth was in a thin line. “I realize now that your brother offended you by asking me to teach you to be a more proficient seamstress, but perhaps be angry with him and not me. All I want to do is help.”

“You—”

“As for leaving Roslyn, I do not think that will be happening anytime soon. Setting aside the fact that my brothers are very intent on opening this store, we have a lease signed for at least three years.” Less of a lie, that one, more of a stretch. “We do not have to be friends, Miss Barrow, but my family is establishing ourselves in the community here so you and I might as well learn how to tolerate each other.”

They stared at each other, Maggie firm, Louise irritated.

“So, you truly heard my sister-in-law and spoke for her to my brother?”

Maggie hesitated. The truth was a living thing which sometimes needed to be bent without being broken. “It isn’t like this conversation with you. It’s faint and sometimes unclear, and much of it relies on how their presence makes me feel. But your brother came in and asked for her, and I told him what I experienced.” She held Louise’s gaze. “You may well condemn me as a fraud, and I will not be able to disprove you. Or you could believe that Sarah loved Theo so well that death could not stop it.”

Louise didn’t smile, but she didn’t exactly frown, either. “Sarah was my best friend, Miss Cruthers, and my brother is very important to me. I will do whatever I can to protect him and her memory.”

“I can see that.”

“I do not believe in magic, or the Lord working in mysterious ways, or people being cursed. I believe in facts and things I can see with my eyes.”

“As do I.”

Louise gave her an assessing gaze. “I do not think we will be friends, but if my brother thinks you can help me improve my craft, I will humble myself by accepting.” She looked uncomfortable, and Maggie couldn’t bring herself to feel smug.

“All right,” she said, and a fragile, reluctant alliance was forged.

It probably wouldn’t be that bad, anyway.

Chapter

Seven

“I don’t like it.” Jake punched the dough on the counter with unnecessary violence, and Theo watched from a distance as his brother continued his assault on the glutenous mass that had never hurt anyone.

“You don’t like most things,” Theo pointed out, taking a sip of coffee. “That doesn’t particularly impress me.”

“You weren’t at church, Theo.” No one was at church, Theo thought. Even he knew how ill-attended Sam’s services were. “You didn’t see the way that brother of hers went after the reverend like a dog after a bone with a bit of meat on it.” Jake gave the dough another thwack before dumping it into a glass bowl to rise. “The entire family gives me itchy skin. Are we really supposed to believe that they’re related? They all couldn’t look more different if they tried. It’s ridiculous and insulting, is what it is.”

Theo leaned back, crossing his arms. Louise was at the warehouse with David, helping clean birds for the shop, and Emmy had just gone down for her nap, so he and Jake had a rare afternoon alone. As soon as their siblings had left, Jake insisted on making bread for dinner and lecturing Theo about the immorality of associating with the Cruthers. Well on his way to becoming an insufferable zealot, he rarely read the good book itself but nonetheless reveled in positioning himself as the moral compass of the family, the unelected representative of the Lord at the Barrow hearth.

Naturally, he was being summarily ignored. Theo had hoped that this would discourage him, but it seemed to only heighten his fervor. Privately, David and Theo had discussed the possibility of telling Jake that all the knocks to the head were rendering him unbearable to be around, but they were afraid he might do something truly insane like go to a faith healer. Perhaps Sam could dip him in some holy water or something of the sort.

“You seem to have given this a great deal of thought.” Theo idly pushed his coffee cup around the table. “Sam is a pleasant chap, outwardly. Sort of.” Well, that was a lie. Sam was a preachy, rude chap, but his heart was in the right place. Hopefully. “Perhaps you misread the situation, and Mr. Cruthers was only trying to be friendly to the town pastor. He’s very outgoing.”