AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

Magdalene Cruthers Is Going To Hell

Page 31

by Ali Lockhart

“Don’t listen to him,” Maggie cooed, breaking away from the boys and approaching Theo. “You greet me any way you want.” Emmy reached her arms out, and Maggie took her in, kissing her cheek before settling her on her hip. The room melted away, a cacophony of muddled, muted sounds, and all she saw was Theo, pink-cheeked and stretching his arms out to shake off the dust from outside. “We’re liable to get blown into the next county,” he observed, scanning the room before settling his gaze on Maggie. They crinkled; the dimple appeared, cheeky, tucked under his left eye. Maggie wanted to lean forward and kiss it. Flushing, she straightened, bouncing Emmy. “How has your day been?”

He ran a hand through his hair, sighing, and it didn’t help matters at all. Now she was thinking about how normal this felt, how natural it would be to sit with Theo at the end of the day and exchange how it had gone for each of them. Emmy was there, making her usual grunts, and Theo was rumpled and lovely, and Maggie was bursting out of her own skin. She wanted to bring him tea and a sandwich; she wanted to rub the tension out of his shoulders. She wanted to hold this baby forever.

She wanted to leave, a little.

“Here,” She offered Emmy back to Theo, who took her with a furrowed brow. Emmy turned in her father’s arms to glare at Maggie, clearly marking the rejection. “I should get back to my brothers.”

“Is that Sam with them?” Theo’s gaze, slightly narrow, was fixed on Tom and Bridgers as they made polite conversation with the reverend, who kept casting glances at her. “He’s been popping up with some regularity as of late.”

“How well do you know him?” Maggie asked, ignoring Emmy’s pout.

“Oh, well enough.” He kissed the top of Emmy’s head. “We’re the same age, went to school together. He’s only been at the pulpit for two or so years and … Well, perhaps Lou has mentioned that our brother, Jake, has taken an interest in, er, the Lord lately, and Sam hasn’t really been helping.”

Maggie scrunched her eyebrows. “Not helping how?”

Theo shrugged. “Jake’s been rather a pain about it, and I wish Sam would set him straight. Instead, he’s encouraged some, er, rather insufferable judgment and whatnot.” Maggie’s gut twisted. She looked at Tom, who was standing too near Bridgers. “He hasn’t been bothering you, has he?”

She snapped her attention back to Theo. “Jake?”

Theo smiled. “Sam.”

She kept looking at his mouth. She needed to get away before she did something foolish. “No, he’s just … friendly. I should go.”

His disappointed expression was brief, but it hit her like the gales outside. “Of course.”

She paused. She was being silly. It was perfectly normal to be attracted to a handsome man who knew how to hold a baby. There was no need to be dramatic. Wasn’t she testing the waters of honesty? “He, ah, expressed an interest in courting me.”

Theo’s face, normally so expressive, went blank. His brow softened, every line disappearing, and his shoulders slumped. “I see.” He paused. “He’s a decent man.” His mouth twisted slightly.

“A ringing endorsement,” Maggie replied dryly. “He hasn’t spoken to me yet, just … asked Tom and Bridgers for their blessing.”

A tic—a tiny fluttering, barely noticeable—quirked in Theo’s cheek. “Oh?” Emmy was babbling, droning on about something very important, and he ignored her. “And what did they say?” He swallowed hard, glancing at the barkeep.

Maggie stood rooted to the spot, an unexpected swell of satisfaction breaking over her like a wave: Theo Barrow was jealous. Oh, this was too delicious. Theo cared. Theo was bothered. A bubble was about to escape her, carrying some sort of love-sick songbird, and Maggie reached for Emmy again, for distraction in the form of a soft, dimpled cherub who liked to bite things. Theo handed her over easily, almost reflexively, and the baby settled onto Maggie’s hip once more. She was chattering again; Maggie heard a distinct papa mixed in there, and she grinned. “Who’s your papa?” she asked, turning so Emmy could see Theo. Emmy paused, blinking at Maggie, before throwing her fist towards her father, another stream of nonsense flowing out of her mouth.

“Yes,” Theo said, giving a smile that looked rather like a wince. “I’m your papa, darling.” He reached up and gripped her little hand, shaking it. “A pleasure to meet you.” He withdrew his hand. “I think I’ll get myself a pint.” Maggie silently handed him hers, half-drained, and he looked at it warily. “No, thank you, I’ll get my own. If you don’t mind staying with her for a moment?” He disappeared into the crowd without waiting for an answer, his dark head bobbing among the patrons. Emmy, who had not paused in her soliloquy, continued with her rambles, now prodding at Maggie’s face with undisguised mischief. Maggie gulped the rest of her beer, kissed Emmy on the temple, and shifted her higher. She really should tell Theo nothing was going on between her and the reverend; as warm and glowing as his jealousy made her feel, she didn’t like the idea of him in distress. At least, she was fairly certain that’s what this twinge was. She glanced at her brothers, who stared at her with looks of utter bewilderment (Bridgers) and barely-muted humor (Tom).

“I can take her,” Theo said, reemerging from the crowd. He slipped into her space easily.

The idea stuck in the front of her mind. Theo just slipped into her life so easily. She felt her neck heat up.

“I’m not interested,” she blurted. He looked at her blankly. “In the reverend.”

“You aren’t interested in the reverend.”

“No, I’m not. I’m … Well, I’m –”

She barely had time to register the look on Theo’s face—a sort of agonized relief—when shouts rose from the crowd. The wind outside had heightened, and it was whistling through cracks in the wall of the tavern; the atmosphere of the crowd seemed to be excited rather than alarmed.

“Disgusting,” a voice beside her said, and she jumped, jostling Emmy. The little one released a short wail, clutching Maggie’s arm and staring at her with wide, indignant eyes. “I’m sorry, sweet,” Maggie soothed. “I’m sorry. Here’s Papa.” She handed her over to Theo, who took her with his free arm. She turned to the offending voice; it was Sam, of course. She was beginning to wonder if she had recently grown irresistible.

"What’s disgusting?” She knew she could stand to have a more polite tone, but the man was irritating her.

Sam, clutching a glass of milk (she was oddly offended by it, despite having no ill feelings towards milk in general), nodded towards the corner of the room. “The winds forced some of the stall-runners indoors and a woman is reading fortunes in the back. Crystal ball or some nonsense.”

“Card reading,” Theo said shortly, keeping his beer away from Emmy with impressive dexterity. “Tarot.”

Tarot. Maggie waited, briefly, for the iron-heavy weight to settle on her; the electric panic that usually shot through her veins whenever anything relating to spiritualism or the occult had been mentioned since the move to Roslyn, but she only felt a twinge of interest. “Oh?” she asked, raising an eyebrow. “Perhaps you could get a reading, Reverend.”