Magdalene Cruthers Is Going To Hell
Page 54
Theo made dinner at Maggie’s house this time. The kitchen was smaller than his, the stove more persnickety, and he over seasoned the stew, but Maggie couldn’t bring herself to even tease him. She was happily dipping brown bread into her bowl, enjoying the tang of the hot peppers he had used, the subtle complexity of the spices. He had eaten his bowl rapidly, ignoring the heat of it, and was watching her with a wry smile. “I must have done good.”
She nodded, taking a swallow of wine. “You know I can’t cook, and Bridgers under-salts everything. This was delightful.”
He bowed in his chair slightly. “At your service.” He examined the wine in his glass. “I’m sure you can cook. It just takes practice.”
She snorted; very ladylike. “I’ve tried for years. It’s remarkable how often I can overcook or undercook. I tried to make roasted pork once and Tom spent the entire night being sick as a dog.”
Theo’s mouth twitched. “He’s a very charming man, that Tom. Lou is rather fond of him.”
Maggie crinkled her nose. “She’s fond of Bridgers, you mean.”
“Oh, very, but she finds Tom’s scowling to be endearing. Says it makes him look like a grumpy bear.”
Filing that away for later, Maggie watched Theo silently stand to ladle more stew into his bowl, snagging another loaf of bread on his way back to the table.
“Where are they tonight?” Theo’s tone was neutral, his eyes fixed on his bowl of stew, the bread he dunked into it.
“Some play,” she said, fiddling with the napkin on her lap. The wine was sinking into her, muddling the front of her mind. “A Shakespeare, I think. Or a parody? I don’t recall. It’s at the pavilion.” The pavilion was the cultural center of Roslyn, being the default host to any performance that was worthy of shelter. When Maggie had introduced the possibility of Theo making dinner, Bridgers had casually mentioned a Comedy of Errors adaptation happening that evening and implied it was a long-term plan he hadn’t invented on the spot. Tom had offered little argument, aside from a clearly improvised grumble about disliking this particular play, and they had made themselves scarce.
“How long has that been happening?” Theo carefully dipped his bread into his bowl and Maggie’s dull senses were confused.
“How long has what been happening?”
Theo shrugged, looking up at her. “Tom and Bridgers. I assume it isn’t new.”
The wave of terror nearly knocked Maggie over; she reeled back, scooting her chair behind her several feet. “What do you mean?”
“How long have they been a couple?” He smiled easily, and Maggie wanted to scream. This was the worst possibility: someone she cared for finding out about the boys, holding the threat over her head like the sword of Damocles. She felt her dinner making its way upwards.
“They’re not,” she said, thinly. “How could you say that? They’re my brothers.”
Theo was looking at her strangely. “Sweetheart,” he said, and she bunched her napkin tight into her hand. “I know you love them. It’s all right.”
“You can’t tell anyone,” Maggie’s voice was higher, slightly hysterical, and she stood from her chair because if she kept sitting, she would sink through the floor. “Please don’t tell anyone. Theo, please.” Her words were garbling together like she was drunk, but it was panic. “Theo, no one can know. It’s too dangerous. Nothing can happen to them. Please.” Her heart was racing; it slammed against her ribcage. They had been careful. Hadn’t they been careful? They never touched in public; they never even exchanged long looks.
Theo’s eyes were so wide, wider than she’d ever seen, and his mouth opened and closed twice before he found words. “I won’t. I promise. They’re safe, Maggie, I promise. Don’t look so scared. I’m sorry, sweetheart; don’t be scared. I’m sorry.”
“They aren’t safe,” she replied, without an ounce of steadiness. “They are always in danger. Please don’t tell anyone.” Why has she had so much wine? She sounded thick. She couldn’t convey the magnitude of this to him, not like this.
Theo stood, too, and wordlessly strode over to her. His big arms wrapped around her shoulders, and she rested her forehead on his chest. “They aren’t safe, Theo. They’re never safe.”
“They’re safe here.” He was stroking her back gently, his chin on top of her head. “I promise, I’ll keep them safe.”
It was hard not to believe Theo when his voice was so steady above her, his arms so firmly around her body. She listened to the slow draw and release of his breathing, timing it to her own, and let herself be held.
And so, it was in the comforting prison of his arms, tucked tightly against him, that Maggie finally let herself sink into the warm waters she had been treading.
She was in love with Theo Barrow.
He kissed her forehead. She pushed her face into his chest again, and he sighed.
“It must be exhausting,” he said carefully, “having to carry that burden.”
“It isn’t,” she said into him, her voice muffled. “They’re my brothers. I love them.”
“Difficult for them, I mean.” He swallowed; she heard it, felt the soft bob of his throat. “I can’t imagine living in such silence. Having to hide like that.”
She nodded. “It’s hard. It … costs them.” More now than ever, she was realizing. She knew about hiding a bit, did Maggie, but nothing like that. “How did you know?”