Magdalene Cruthers Is Going To Hell
Page 59
“That wouldn’t be proper.”
“Oh, for Christ’s sake, Maggie.” Lou dropped her piece into her lap and glared. “Just sneak along the shadows in the middle of the night like a normal person.”
“I don’t think I want to do that.” She very much wanted to do that.
Lou sighed. “Just go to the house tonight. He’s always home by five at the latest, and Emmy is in bed by seven thirty.”
“You want to eavesdrop on me humbling myself?”
“I’ll spend the night at David’s.”
Sudden awareness struck like a brick. “That isn’t necessary.”
“For my own sanity, I think it is.”
Chapter
Nineteen
Which was how Maggie found herself staring at Theo’s front door, paralyzed by an unpleasant combination of anticipation and terror. She was going to wake Emmy up. She was going to expose too much. She was going to be sick.
She raised her hand for the fourth time, mentally preparing herself to knock—not too hard, just enough to perhaps maybe get his attention—and not to be disappointed if he didn’t answer the door. She didn’t have the opportunity to be a coward again, though, as the door opened before she could touch it.
“Yes?” Theo said, completely unfazed to see her standing at his door in the dark.
“I … Hello.”
“Hello.” He didn’t move.
“Can I come in?”
Silently, Theo stood aside and Maggie walked past him, turning to face him as he shut the door behind her.
“What can I—” he started just as she said, “I’m sorry to—"
His mouth snapped shut. Maggie drew a breath.
“I’m sorry to intrude,” she tried again. “I don’t like how we left things. I wanted to apologize.”
“You don’t need to apologize,” Theo said, moving past her and dropping himself into a chair near the unlit fireplace. He nodded to the sofa next to him and she sat down on it, moving slowly as though quick movements would spook him.
“I do,” she said. “I was unfair and I’m sorry.”
Theo sank into his chair. “I’m sorry, too. I should know better than to ask personal questions.”
The hair on Maggie’s arm rose. “What does that mean?”
He shrugged. “You keep your cards close to the chest. I know that.”
“I’m trying to be better.” She hadn’t meant for the words to come out so wispy, so pathetic, but they had, and his brows furrowed.
“You don’t need to be better, Maggie. You just need to be you. I can work around whatever you give me.”
“I want to be better for you,” she insisted, sounding a little pathetic. “You deserve … more, Theo, and I’m sorry I’m struggling. I’m sorry I’m so closed off.” It was how she saw herself these days, locked up in a room in her own mind, unable to coexist with the world in any way that mattered.
“You’re not closed off, sweetheart,” he replied. “I wish you could know what I see when I look at you.” He colored. “You’re warm and welcoming. You let me in, Maggie, and I know that isn’t easy for you. You let me in.”
She felt her smile tremble and pressed her lips together. “Sometimes I feel like I don’t deserve you.”