Page 113

He was sitting on a wide shelf of granite that jutted out over the water, his back to her, his shoulders dusted with frost, a thermos beside him and no fishing line in the lake at all. He was turning around.

She had spent all night on a speech. She had it ready. What came out instead was:

“Inventory,” she said.

* * *

He stood up slowly.

He looked at her like he wasn’t sure she was real. Like she was something the lake had made up.

“How did you...” he started.

“Doug,” she said. And then, after a moment: “Mostly Doug.”

“Doug doesn’t leave the counter.”

“He came out without his coat,” she said. “That’s how I knew it was bad.”

Shane closed his eyes for a second.

“He also told me you did inventory in November,” she said.

He opened them again. He didn’t argue.

She walked out onto the granite. It was icy and she went carefully. He started to reach for her and stopped himself halfway, and she saw him do it, and she saw how much it cost him. She sat down on the cold stone beside where he’d been sitting. After a moment, he sat down too.

Neither of them spoke for a while.

The lake lay dark and flat in front of them, a skin of ice along the shore and open water beyond it, and the sky over the mountains had gone from black to the deep blue that comes before gray. Their breath rose together and disappeared.

“You pulled back,” she said finally.

“I know.”

“You nodded at me.” Her voice cracked on it and she let it. “From the ladder. Like September. Like I was somebody new in town.”

“I know.”

“I need to know why.”

He was quiet for a long moment. She watched him decide. She watched him choose, the way he chose everything, and this time he chose the true thing.

“Rick came in Monday,” he said. “Told me you laughed at your phone right after I left. And I’d seen you turn it over when I walked in. Fast. Like you didn’t want me to see.” He looked at the lake. “It wasn’t jealousy. I want you to know that. I’m not that. It was that I’d told you about the letter. The drawer. I’ve never told anybody about that drawer. And then you turned something over so I couldn’t see it.”

She closed her eyes.

“And then I realized I didn’t know what we were,” he said. “I never asked. You asked me to dinner. You said stay. You said you didn’t want to keep almost. I followed you every step, and I never once asked you anything real. The only text I’ve ever sent you on my own was about propane.”

A laugh broke out of her, small and damp.

“And under all of it,” he said, quieter, “there’s this other thing.” He took a breath. “People come to Merrybrook to get well. Everybody who’s lived here long enough knows it. They come here with something broken and the town holds them for a while. And some of them get well and stay. And some of them get well and go back to wherever they came from.” He was looking at his hands now. “There was a woman a few years ago. From Billings. I watched the town fold up around the space she left. And I thought, you came here after somebody who didn’t choose you. What if he called. What if I’m just the lake and the coffee and the pie. The thing that held you while you got better.”

She didn’t say anything. She couldn’t.

“I don’t do this,” he said. “I don’t let people in who might leave. I’ve spent my whole life being what this town needed, and I don’t know how to need somebody back without being scared out of my mind about the day they go.” He shook his head once. “So I got useful. I told myself I was giving you space. Harold came in yesterday and told me what that’s actually called.”

“What’s it called?”