Page 146
Just be ready. He added a face emoji with the eyes rolling and the tongue sticking out.
Still smiling, I went inside, made myself a Vegemite sandwich, and set up my microphone and laptop at Parker’s dining table.
Then I called Nancy.
We spent a few minutes on pleasantries before I asked if she felt ready to record the interview. She agreed.
“I thought it might be nicer if we could see each other,” I said. “Do you have FaceTime?”
“I do. My grandson downloaded it for me a while ago. He lives in Perth. That’s how I chat with him. How do I do it again?”
I reminded her what to do, then ended the call and tapped the FaceTime icon beside her name.
For several dizzying seconds, I saw part of Nancy’s forehead, a floral curtain, and an extreme close-up of one watery blue eye.
“Oh, goodness,” she muttered. “Where have you gone?”
“I’m here. Hold the phone a little farther away.”
Her whole face appeared.
“There you are,” I said.
“There you are.” She smiled, deepening all the lines around her eyes.
“Now prop the phone against something so you don’t have to hold it the entire time.”
After some fumbling and a brief tour of her ceiling, Nancy settled the phone against a stack of books. She sat in a floral armchair in the front room of her home, and afternoon light spilled gold through the curtains behind her, making the gray streaks in her hair look silver.
I explained how the interview would work and reminded her that she could stop at any time. Once she confirmed she was comfortable being recorded, I switched on my microphone.
Then, across hundreds of miles and half a century of silence, we began talking about Katrina Sutton.
Whit had already given Nancy the facts about her niece’s death, but I wanted Nancy to tell us about her life.
“What was Katrina like?” I asked.
Nancy’s face brightened. “Oh, she was a handful.” A smile tugged at her mouth. “Funny and fierce and impossible when she wanted to be. Which was most of the time.”
She told me about Katrina’s love of horses, although she’d never had one of her own. How she’d save scraps of bread to feed the birds and once kidnapped a neighbor’s dog because she was convinced they didn’t love him enough.
“She hid him in her bedroom for two days,” Nancy said. “She’d sneak food off her dinner plate to feed him. None of us knew a thing until Mrs. Kennedy heard him barking through the wall.”
I laughed as Nancy told more stories.
Katrina rolled her eyes at adults. Sang too loudly. Stomped her foot when she was mad. Chewed gum constantly and stuck it beneath the kitchen table despite denying it every time she was caught. She was stubborn, reckless, fun, and desperate to be older.
As Nancy talked, Katrina’s life formed piece by piece.
A girl who had existed as a sad memory and a nickname on an autopsy file became a whole person again.
Not the barrel girl.
Not merely Kat.
Katrina Sutton.
At a gap in her stories, I braced for the question I’d dreaded. “You told me when we first spoke that Katrina ran away from home a few times. Do you want to tell everyone why?”