AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

What Did They Fear?

Page 67

by Kendall Talbot

He clicked his tongue against his teeth. “I’m sure there are details about him in the police report.” He strode over to a stack of boxes against the left wall and lifted the lid of the top one. “It’ll be in one of these boxes.”

I pointed at the desk against the opposite wall, topped with books and stationery that were disturbingly neat. Whit’s not going to like how messy things are going to get in here. “Can you clear that off for me? And do you have a fresh notepad I can use? I work better when I can jot things down.”

“Okay,” he said, marching over to the desk.

I reached into the open box and pulled out a thick manila folder. The front was labeled in faded blue ink: Charlotte and Lola’s Friends. I flipped it open, hoping for a structured list or a set of interviews. Instead, I was greeted by a bunch of handwritten notes on yellow legal pads, photographs and photocopies of what looked like diary pages, and a high school yearbook. I put that aside for later.

The box was a disorganized jumble from two decades ago. Much of it would be completely useless. But it highlighted what I was actually up against. A heavy weight settled in my chest. This wasn’t going to be a quick, neat puzzle to solve. It would take a long time to sift through mountains of paperwork to find something that might have been missed. It would be like nearly every other cold case I’d dug into: tedious, frustrating, exhausting, but hopefully not completely worthless.

“What do you want me to do?” Whit asked.

I set the folder on the cleared desk. “Just work with me. I’ll be asking lots of questions.”

“Okay, I’ll grab another chair.” He strode from the room and seemed to have a slight spring in his step.

Working side by side, the hours bled into one another as we sorted, cross-referenced, and began the agonizing process of dismantling a twenty-year-old cold case so we could rebuild it from scratch. We spent nearly the entire day in that room, only stopping for quick bathroom breaks, to grab water and snacks, and to swap over the laundry.

Working together, we started by dividing the paperwork mountain into official police records and the brothers’ personal files. From the official stack, we extracted every document bearing Bob Ackerman’s name. There were surprisingly few, which only made my stomach twist more. Then, we split the brothers’ twenty years of work into two distinct piles: concrete evidence and pure speculation.

I went through the original missing-person reports and the fruitless bushland search logs. I scanned over the cruel press clippings that had smeared the brothers. I studied hand-drawn maps, meticulous timelines, and a list of every dead lead the brothers had ever chased.

I asked so many questions. Some of them Whit knew the answers to straight away; others required us to dig into the boxes, coughing on the rising dust. Some questions didn’t have answers at all, so I’d jot them into my notebook, highlighting them with heavy circles, underlines, and asterisks, or giving them their own dedicated page.

As the hours rolled on, the pages of the notepad filled with my doodling, questions, names, and arrows connecting disparate details. Most of it was useless noise, but it was my method. Writing things down by hand clocked them into my memory, filing them away for later when a connection might finally click.

By the time the afternoon light began to fade, casting a bruised purple hue across the windows, sheer mental exhaustion caught up with us.

Whit dropped a heavy stack of files onto the desk, and dust swirled in the dim light. He rubbed the back of his neck, his shoulders slumping as he let out a long, ragged breath. He looked shattered. The physical toll of dragging his sister’s ghost into the light for me was written in the deep lines around his eyes.

He cleared his throat. “I don’t know about you, but I’m just about done for today, and I’m getting hungry.”

I could have kept going all night, but I knew he wouldn’t stop unless I did. “Yeah, my brain is officially mush. Sign me up for Vegemite on toast again.”

He managed a small, tired smile. “I think I can do better than that. We have a great Thai restaurant in town. Do you like Thai food?”

“Hell yes. I’d kill for Thai,” I said.

“Any favorites?”

“Red curry. Chili cashew. Fish cakes. Honestly, I love all of it, so I’ll eat whatever you order.”

“Red curry, it is,” he said. “How about you go take a shower while I order us some dinner?” He stepped toward me, then paused, his hand hovering near my shoulder as if he wanted to touch me but thought better of it. He cleared his throat, looking a little self-conscious. “When you’re done ... I’ll be waiting … to dress your wounds, that is. Not ... not waiting in a weird way. Just ... I’ll have the first-aid kit ready.”

A tiny smile tugged at the corner of my mouth. The predictable, forensic pathologist was suddenly tripping over his words. “I didn’t think you were being weird, Whit.”

“Right. Good. Do you need help removing the bandages?” He rubbed his jaw, brushing his fingers over his beard stubble that was growing thicker by the day.

“No, I’m fine.”

“Okay. Go shower. Call me when you’re done.”

I turned away to hide my grin, my heart doing a strange little flutter. In the bathroom, I removed the bandages. The deep cuts on my left leg had begun to dry out, forming dark, tight scabs. It was still a canvas of deep purple and yellowing bruises, and was bloody sore to the touch, but the swelling had gone down a bit. My bloodshot eye was fading to a dull pink, and the bump on my forehead had shrunk and no longer throbbed like mad.

I wrapped my legs in cling film and took a long, hot shower, letting the steaming water wash away the day’s dust and the heavy, emotional weight of those files. When I stepped out, I changed into the few clean clothes we’d salvaged from the wreckage of my Kombi: a well-worn, faded T-shirt and denim shorts.

Putting on my own clothes felt like reclaiming a scrap of my independence. I’d never worn a man’s clothes before, and as I folded his shirt and set it on the counter, I couldn’t deny how strangely nice it had been. I shook the thought away, refusing to let myself analyze it.

I opened the bathroom door and called downstairs, “Ready for my doctor now.”