AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

What Did They Fear?

Page 80

by Kendall Talbot

“No,” I said, shutting his laptop and looking up at him. “Not yet. I did a brief teaser about the podcast, that’s all. The rest isn’t ready yet. I have more to check.”

Some of the heavy tension drained from his broad shoulders, but not all of it. The argument we had yesterday still sat between us, unfinished, but neither of us said so.

“I did call Michelle, though,” I said, pushing back on the stool. “It was so hard.”

“I bet it was.” His eyes softened. “How is she?”

“Broken.” I swallowed. “But she said she wants the world to know her daughter was found, and for everyone to know her killer is still out there.”

The words sat in my chest like a stone. The same stone I’d carried for Celeste for years.

“You hungry?” he asked.

The change of subject caught me off-guard. “Starving. What are we cooking?” I’d come to love our nightly ritual of making dinner together.

Whit leaned against the counter. “Actually, I was hoping you’d come to dinner with me. It’s my family’s standing Thursday night roast.”

I blinked, completely thrown. “And here I was thinking you liked keeping me locked up in your house.”

Underneath the joke, my stomach knotted. I didn’t do family, but it was more than that. I’d spent days living inside his family’s worst nightmare, reading the old police transcripts of every Callahan grilled by detectives, including the interviews where Whit himself had been treated like a suspect. I’d be sitting at their table, knowing more about their darkest days than they knew about me.

“It might do you good to get out of these four walls.” A small smile tugged at his mouth. “And Mom wants to meet you.”

“She does?”

“Jaxson told her about the cliff rescue. Parker told her about your podcast.” He shrugged. “Word gets around.”

“Oh, God. I don’t know.”

“Why not?”

I looked down at my hands. “I’m not good with family stuff.”

He pulled over a stool and sat facing me. “What do you mean?”

I stared at him, my throat suddenly tight. The instinct to deflect, to throw up a wall and crack a joke was a gift I’d spent years perfecting. It was so much safer to keep my past locked in the dark. But as I met his pleading gaze, I realized how much of himself he had already given me. He had opened his home and the raw, aching history of his family’s deepest wound to me. He had let me into his life, and if I was honest with myself, I wanted to let him into mine, too. I needed to.

I took a steadying breath and let the armor drop.

“After Celeste was murdered, my parents poured everything into what happened to her. Which, of course, was the right thing to do. But somewhere along the way, I just stopped existing as their daughter.” I heaved a breath. “They tore each other apart over whose fault it was, even though neither of them could be blamed. Their blame turned into hate. In the end, they couldn’t even look at each other. They divorced eighteen months after Celeste was murdered.”

“Ah, shit, Angel.” He rested his hand over my wrist. “I’m sorry.”

“A year after that, Dad remarried and moved to Perth. I haven’t seen him in eight years.” My voice went hollow. “Mom turned to the church. Every time I visit her, which isn’t often, she gives me a sermon about God’s mysterious ways until I want to scream.” I shrugged. “So yeah … when Celeste died, I didn’t just lose a sister, I lost my whole family.”

Whit was quiet for a moment, his thumb moving slowly over the inside of my wrist. He knew nothing he could say would help.

“You can’t choose your family, right?” I said, trying to lighten the conversation.

“That’s true. On that note, you need to meet mine.” He stood and offered his hand. “Come and see for yourself. Just, fair warning about my dad, he hasn’t been the same since Charlotte vanished. If he barely says two words to you, don’t take it to heart. Some days, he’s not really there.”

“Okay.” I breathed out and took his hand. “Just make sure we sit together.”

“Absolutely.” He smiled, and his eyes lit up in a way I hadn’t seen before. Oh, God, he really wants me to meet his family.

Please don’t let me screw this up.

We went down to the garage, and I slipped on my new slides. They were cheap and plastic, but they matched my simple outfit well enough that I didn’t look completely homeless. I just hoped his mom wouldn’t mind that I was dressed so casually for dinner.