Page 60
"He lied to you, Elizabeth."
I shake my head automatically. A reflex, maybe. "He was a priest."
"No." The answer comes from the priest this time. His voice breaks slightly. "He wore the clothes, Elizabeth, but what you described isn't what God asks of people." I look at him. Really look at him, and I realize he's crying. "And none of it was your fault."
None of this makes sense.
Because if it wasn't my fault...
If Father lied...
If the teachings weren't lessons...
Then I don't know what they were, and for the first time since waking up in the hospital, I realize that maybe my entire life at Sanctum has been one big lie.
The room feels strangely quiet now, and I don’t realize I’m holding my breath until my chest begins to ache. My eyes drift down to my hands, watching my fingers curl against the blanket as if they’ll somehow find the answer hidden in the fabric. I try to fit everything they've said into the life I've always known. The harder I try, the less any of it makes sense. Father had an answer for everything. There was always a reason, always a lesson, always a verse to explain why something hurt.
Father… The commandments… The teachings… Punishments… Prayer.
One by one, they stop fitting together.
If Father lied, then why would god have allowed it? If the teachings weren’t lessons, then why did they happen every Sunday after prayer while the other wives taught each other?
If none of it was my fault, then why does it feel like it is?
The questions arrive faster than I can answer them, each one pulling another thread loose until the picture I've carried in my head for fifteen years begins to unravel. I don't know which part to hold onto anymore. Father built my entire world one rule at a time, and now, with only a handful of sentences, Felix and the priest have somehow made every one of those rules feel uncertain.
“If… if it wasn’t teaching…” I hesitate, searching for the right words. “Then what was I supposed to call it?”
Neither of them answers, and I lift my head slowly. The priest is still watching me, but he looks heartbroken, and I don’t know why.
“Was I supposed to say no?”
Felix swallows hard, but he still doesn’t say anything, just opens and closes his mouth a few times.
“I didn’t know that I could,” I say. Felix’s face drains of what little color it still had, and I don’t understand why. I keep going, though, because I need answers. “He never asked… Was he supposed to?”
The priest looks like he’s going to be sick, and his hand tightens in his lap. For a moment, I think he’s going to pick up the bible and throw it, like Father used to. I don’t understand why… I’ve only answered their questions… I’ve only told them what happened. Yet the longer he looks at me, the more he seems to struggle with whatever thoughts are running through his head.
“If it wasn’t God’s will… then why didn’t He stop it?” I ask him, but the scrape of chair legs against the floor pulls my attention away from him, as Felix jumps to his feet. The movement is so sudden that the chair slams backward into the wall behind him with a sharp crack. The sound tears through the room, making my shoulders jump toward my ears before I can stop them. My pulse spikes, and for a brief moment, I find myself waiting for the correction for asking a question I wasn’t supposed to.
Instead, Felix’s face changes from furious to soft the second he sees me flinch. The anger that was there disappears so quickly that it shocks me. “I’m sorry,” he says to me.
Those words leave me more confused than the outburst itself.
People don’t apologize to me. Ever.
Father never apologized when he hurt someone. Even Harlow only ever apologized when she thought she’d failed to protect me from him. Apologies weren’t something people gave freely in Sanctum. Yet here’s Felix, offering one as naturally as breathing.
He drags both hands down his face, turning away from me as though it physically hurts to look at me. He breathes once, twice, as if he’s trying to regain control. Every line of his body is rigid, his shoulders are tight beneath his shirt, and I can see the tension running through his arm and neck as though he’s physically restraining himself from doing something.
I take the time to look at him—really look at him— for the first time since I met him. I feel like I’ve been in a daze since I woke up; everything is still so new from what I’m used to at Sanctum that I haven’t really had time to notice the people around me.
I suppose that’s what happens when your world consists of four concrete walls, a cross bolted to one of them, and Father’s office once a week. There isn’t much to compare anything to after that. The basement never changed, obviously. The walls stayed the same. The mat stayed in the same corner, and I never dared to move it. Even the cracks in the stone floor became familiar after fifteen years. If I were lucky, I’d see the hallway on my way to the shared bathroom, and on Sundays, I’d be taken upstairs for my lessons before being returned to the basement.
Now, everything is different all at once.
The bed beneath me is softer than anything I’ve ever slept on. The food arrives on trays with colors and smells I don’t recognize. People walk in and out of my room without bowing their heads or asking Father for permission first. They smile at me for no reason I can understand, and nobody seems angry when I don’t know what to say back. There are machines beside my bed, lights that turn on with the flick of a switch, and a television that somehow contains entire worlds inside a black box mounted to the wall.