AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

My Merry Ménage

Page 51

by Lexi Amber

“Second thing. I’m switching you to speakerphone so Patrick, Jace, and Kieran can say hello. We already told them about you and exactly what you mean to us.”

“You what?” he practically screeches into the phone.

There’s a chorus of hellos as everyone greets him, and Jace adds, “Excited to meet you whenever you’re free.”

“Umm, hi,” is all Scotty seems to be able to manage, clearly shocked that we explained our relationship to them.

“Last thing,” I add. “It sounds like you’re home and done with work if you were trying to convince yourself to come over. We’re all still here, so that’s still an option, but we already packed up the leftovers, so we can bring them to you if that’s easier. I meant what I said when you first answered: we want to see you. Even if it’s only for a little while. Jace and Kieran could join us too, if you’re up for it.”

“We’re not taking no for an answer,” Patrick teases, but I think it’s also good Scotty understands how important this is to us both.

After a long pause, he finally responds. “You’d all really come here?”

“We’re on our way,” I confirm with a huge smile, relieved that we’ll finally be seeing him soon.

28

“Hello,” Scotty greets with a very nervous smile as he opens the door to his apartment.

“Hey, sweetheart.” I immediately wrap my arms around his waist and lean in for a kiss. I know he was worried about meeting Jace and Kieran; Joey filled me in on the way over, but I’ve really fucking missed him, and I don’t want to wait another moment to have his mouth on mine.

I pull back quickly, though, so Joey can follow with a kiss of his own.

When they break apart, Scotty’s gaze immediately flies back to the open door. “Did your nephew not come?”

“They’re on their way, but there’s a bakery he and his husband really like around here, so we asked them to pick something up to give the three of us a few minutes,” Joey explains.

“I still can’t believe you’d already told them while I was here freaking out about it,” Scotty mutters quietly, and I’m not sure if we’re even meant to hear him, but I respond anyway.

“That’s why being completely honest with each other is so important. There’s no reason for one of us to suffer through anything alone.” I take his hand and wait for him to meet my gaze before I continue. “Scotty, we have no desire or intention to hide you. When you agreed to go on the date with us, I interpreted that to mean the three of us were entering a relationship. Did I misunderstand that? Is there some reason we shouldn’t have told them?”

“Please tell us everything you’re thinking,” Joey cuts in. “I know it might be uncomfortable, but it really is more important than ever that the three of us communicate well while we’re figuring this out.”

Scotty looks between us before letting out a big sigh. “Maybe we should sit down. I have a lot of thoughts to share.”

Joey lets out a nervous chuckle as I gesture for Scotty to lead the way, taking in his apartment for the first time. It’s clean and modern; there are a few paintings on the walls and sculptures in the space that I immediately appreciate as they catch my attention. The main living area is open concept, but I can only see two doors, which I’m guessing are a bedroom and bathroom.

“I really like your place,” I comment as we settle in at his kitchen table. “Is it a one-bedroom?”

He looks thrown by my question for a moment but shakes off his confusion to answer. “Uh, yeah. Why?”

“Well, if you’re not attached to it, I doubt it’s big enough for the three of us. Neither is our apartment. We’ll probably want to start looking for something bigger soon with how competitive things can get,” I explain my line of thinking, and Joey nods easily in response.

Scotty, on the other hand, is staring at me like I just suggested the three of us quit our jobs to move somewhere we’ve never been, in the middle of nowhere, and open up a business we have no experience in.

“What?” I prompt when he doesn’t say anything.

“You guys want to move out of the apartment you’ve been in for over fifteen years?” he asks, sounding completely dumbfounded by the suggestion.

Joey answers before I can. “We want to be with you, and if these past few days are any indication, that will be a hell of a lot easier if we all live together.”

“And I think it makes the most sense to move into a new space we can grow into all together, rather than try to add you to one we’ve been in for so long,” I add.

“Wow,” Scotty says on an exhale, sinking into his chair. “I know you guys seemed confident when we were leaving Vermont, but I was not expecting this level of commitment so soon.”

“Is it too much?” Joey asks, his brow furrowed with worry.

Scotty shakes his head, still sounding a bit surprised as he responds. “No, honestly, everything you’re saying makes me really happy. I think I’m just trying to wrap my head around it all. I know we’ve always gotten along so well, and obviously the sex is amazing, but I don’t know, Harry wouldn’t even consider rearranging his life for me. There was no discussion or conversation. I wanted to move, and he didn’t, so we were done.”