AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

Evan

Page 5

by Terri Anne Browning

The insult was like a dagger thrust into my chest close to my heart, the blade twisting but not quite reaching the organ yet. Obviously, she didn’t consider that I could have been Evan’s plus-one. The way she looked past me, almost through me, turned the simple dagger into something serrated.

Evan’s handsome face clouded, causing his dimples to fully disappear, something I’d thought was impossible. It made him look older, colder, and deliciously more attractive. “If you didn’t see my date, then you weren’t looking close enough, Cap.”

He draped his arm along the back of my chair, his fingers playing absently with my hair.

She blinked, shifting her gaze to me before comically bouncing it back to Evan. “You’re not serious,” she said with a snide laugh. “You’re here with Shana Newton?”

Across the table, Dad went still, which caused Harlem to abruptly cut himself off mid-sentence as the two of them focused on us. I shot my dad a look, one that told him to rein it in. I didn’t need him fighting my battles. Hell, I wasn’t even sure if this was a battle. Caprice wasn’t worth the energy of a fight, and there wasn’t a man alive worth risking breaking a nail over.

“Shaya,” Evan said my name hard enough to cause Caprice to flinch. “Her name is Shaya. Get it right, or don’t say it at all. And I am dead serious, Cap. I’m here with her. So stop trying to third-wheel my date and leave now before you embarrass yourself more than you already have.”

For several long, tense moments, she sat there staring at him like she couldn’t believe what he’d just said. Or like he was joking and she was waiting for him to hit the punch line. She sat there for so long, a server came up to our table and asked if she needed anything.

“No,” Evan answered for her. “She’s not staying. In fact, she could use some assistance in finding the exit.”

“Evan,” she whispered and, when he just glared at her, whined louder. “Really, Evan?”

“Good night, Caprice,” he said, his tone chilly and final.

With a dramatic scoff, she stood, shooting me a mean scowl. “We are going to talk about this tomorrow,” she warned, speaking to Evan while continuing to glare at me.

“Sorry, can’t. I have a date.”

Caprice was half turned away when he said it, and she quickly twirled back to face him. Her mouth dropped open, no sound coming out, her face just showing wide-eyed shock, as if the idea of Evan going on a date with anyone was preposterous. Snapping her jaw closed so hard I heard her teeth click together, she bounced her gaze to me, and her nose flared like an enraged bull.

“Evan and I are having dinner together tomorrow,” I confirmed, smiling up at her, ignoring the way Dad choked on his drink so badly Harlem had to pound him on the back a few times. Whether it was surprise or amusement, I wasn’t fully sure. Perhaps it was both, because I thought I caught a laugh slip from Dad as he tried to catch his breath.

Up until that moment, I hadn’t made up my mind about going out with Evan, but after seeing the disbelief in her eyes, the mean sneer that was already forming on her lovely face, I solidified my decision. “Just to make it clear, because you seem a little slow, Caprice, you aren’t invited. It’s a date after all.”

Evan

Halfway to Shaya’s house, my phone rang. Mom’s picture popped up on the dash on my Apple CarPlay screen, and I groaned even as I hit the button on the steering wheel to answer the call.

“Why did I have to hear from Hayat that my son is going on a date with Shaya Newton?” she demanded before I’d even said hello.

“Hey, Ma,” I greeted dryly.

“I asked you a question, Evan,” she said with an aggrieved huff that was followed by a loud sniff. “Hayat called me with the intel that she got from Ali, who got it from Charlotte, who heard it from Bentley because Caprice called him.”

As it always did, my stomach knotted at the mention of Ali’s name. Regret and shame still lingered after how I’d behaved regarding my once best friend. Back then, I’d lost sight of who I should have been protecting and, instead, focused all my loyalty on Caprice. Since then, I’d been caught in a loop, always jumping in to save the day and keep Cap safe in hopes it would somehow make how I’d let Ali down worth it in some way. It never did, yet I’d continued to do the same thing over and over, expecting a different outcome.

And then I saw Shaya the night before at the charity event, and clarity finally started to set in.

“That’s a long chain of evidence, Ma,” I commented. “Are you calling me to confirm the facts?”

“Absolutely. I always thoroughly fact-check. I am an editor after all.”

“Okay, let’s get the third degree over with. Ask your questions, Madam Editor.”

“Don’t try to butter me up straight out of the gate, boy,” she grumbled. “I got a third-degree tear from your ginormous head and shoulders.”

“Only a third-degree?” I mused, smiling to myself. “Last time, you said it was a fourth-degree.”

Once, I’d made the mistake of doing an internet search on what each degree of tearing during childbirth meant, and those images were still in my head, haunting my dreams at times. That didn’t mean I wouldn’t give her shit about switching between third and fourth degrees, depending on how guilty she wanted me to feel. Her going with a third-degree tear meant she was serious but not pissed. Yet. I was hopeful that wouldn’t change during the conversation.

“You’re going on a date?” She sounded skeptical.

“Yes.”