AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

Hunted on All Hallows’ Eve

Page 21

by Fanny Lee Savage

“Some move,” I mumble.

Noah has the decency to look sheepish. He runs a hand through his hair, leaving it standing on end in a way that makes him look younger, almost boyish. “I meant every word, I said last night, Wren. Every single one.” His eyes find mine. “You’re mine. You have been since we were eighteen, whether you wanted to admit it or not. And if you try to run again, I will chase you. Every time.”

My whole body goes rigid, and my heart tumbles, unsure what to do with the heaviness of his words. There’s a want that has been living in me for ten years, buried under anger and pride but now…

“I need to get back to Aunt June’s,” I say, because it’s the only safe thing I can think of. “I have that paperwork to do. I need my phone. It’s probably—”

“We need to talk,” Noah says, cutting me off gently. He sits up fully, the sheet pooling around his waist, and the morning light catches his chest, making my belly flutter. “There are things you don’t know. Things I should have told you a long time ago.”

Something in his voice makes the air between us go still as he seems to brace himself.

“Okay,” I say, slowly. “But I need clothes.”

He smiles then. “I’ll get you some. Though I’m partial to the view without them.”

I throw a pillow at his head. He catches it one-handed, laughing, and for a moment everything else falls away.

***

Noah’s kitchen is all warm wood and bright morning light. I sit at the small table by the window, my bare feet hooked around the legs of the chair, and watch steam rise from my coffee mug. I’m wearing one of Noah’s flannel shirts and a pair of his old gray sweatpants rolled at the hips so I don’t trip. There’s something about being dressed in his clothes, in his kitchen, that makes my insides feel too full.

Noah leans against the counter, his own mug between his hands. He’s wearing sweats too, and nothing else, and the morning light catches the dusting of dark hair across his chest, the lean muscle of his arms. He looks like he belongs in a movie or on a magazine cover and not an old farmhouse kitchen tucked away at the back of the Dune property.

“Last night,” I say, wrapping both hands around my mug for warmth. “You said you’d clarify what actually happened. With Debra.”

Noah takes a sip of his coffee, sets the mug down, and meets my eyes. “It was a dare. Stupid, drunk, eighteen-year-old boy shit.” His voice is quiet, matter-of-fact. “Some guys from the football team spiked the punch. They’d been fucking with me me for months about the way I talked about you.” He grins and my insides warm. “Which was constantly, by the way.”

“You talked about me?” I ask. “The quiet girl with only one friend?”

Noah tilts his head to the side, brows furrowing. “I was extremely taken with that quiet girl,” he says, then looks to his feet. “But I never told the team about us, about that night at the bonfire, because I didn’t want them all over you, talking about you.”

“I’m sure it had nothing to do with being embarrassed you liked the unpopular girl.”

“The thought of your name in their mouths sent me into a rage.” He scowls at me, but then says. “They fucked with me because I never dated. One of them said I was all talk. Said I’d never actually kissed anyone because I was hung up on a girl who was too sweet to open her thighs for me.” He runs a thumb along the edge of his mug, not meeting my eyes. “So I kissed Debra when they dared me to prove I could snag the prom queen if I wanted. For approximately one minute, before I realized what a colossal ass I was being. And when I stopped, I looked up, and you were right there. And then you ran away. I tried to go after you, but Coach grabbed me. Someone blamed me for spiking the punch. He called my dad. And I spent the entire night and the week after grounded, wishing I could take that stupid kiss back.”

I sag in my seat, absorbing the words. Ten years of carrying that image. Noah and Debra, her hands in his hair, his mouth on hers, and it was one minute of drunken idiocy. One stupid mistake by a boy trying to prove something to his friends.

“But what you said to me,” I say. “That night by the bonfire. Did you mean any of it?”

“Every fucking word.” The certainty in his voice and the dark, verging on deadly gleam in his eyes hits me right in the chest. “I meant every goddamn word, Wren. I loved you. I still do.”

The three words hang in the air, and goosebumps break out along my arms.

“Then why didn’t you call? Why didn’t you come after me? If you meant it—”

“Because I’d messed up.” He pushes off from the counter and sits next to me. “I hurt you. Bad enough you left. And the longer I waited to contact you, the more convinced I was that you deserved better. That you’d found better, in a city with men who weren't small town boys that held no future other than running a farm.” He looks down at his hands. “So I beat myself up about it. Every time I thought about calling, I talked myself out of it. Every time I almost got in the car to drive to Chicago, I remembered the look on your face when you saw us, and I couldn’t do it.”

Anger rushes up, and I’m about to tell him he doesn’t get to decide what I deserve, but the raw honesty in his voice rings me out, leaving just a dull, aching regret for all the time we wasted.

“And then my dad got sick a year after I graduated,” Noah says.

The words hit like a punch to the gut. “What?”

“Cancer,” he says quietly, his eyes on his coffee mug. “We kept it quiet. He didn’t want anyone knowing. His pride, mostly. Said he didn’t want people looking at him with that face.” Noah’s jaw works. “He went to Dayton for treatment. I drove him every week. June was the only one who knew. She helped when it got bad. When he couldn’t keep food down. She’d come over and sit with him so I could sleep, or work, or just breathe for five minutes without worrying.”

My throat closes and I want to reach for him, but I remain still.

“By the time Dad recovered, it had been so long.” Noah looks up at me, meeting my eyes. “That’s why I didn’t come after you, Wren. Not just because I thought you deserved better. Because my dad was sick, and I was nineteen years old, and the idea of dragging you into that, of asking you to come back to this town while—” He stops and swallows, his throat bobbing. “I couldn’t do it. So I let you go. And I’ve regretted it every day since.”