Page 131
"Natalie, we've been over this," I said patiently. "I didn't plan any of it."
"No, I know," she replied. "That's what makes it so unfair."
I stared at her.
"Unfair?"
"Yes, unfair!" Her voice rose slightly. "I've spent my whole life wanting to be a witch, Celeste! My grandmother was a witch, and I always thought that meant I would be one, too. But Nana Cordelia never taught me anything. She wouldn't even tell me how to unlock my powers!"
"Natalie—"
"And then you come along," she continued, ignoring me. "You don't even believe in magic, and suddenly you get to go to Hidden Hollow and meet all these magical people! And you get a familiar, too! My familiar."
Bartleby sniffed.
"I was hardly a prize awarded at a carnival, Natalie. I chose Celeste because she's a witch."
"Nobody asked you!" she snapped.
"Well, maybe somebody ought to," he replied. "Considering that you seem determined to discuss my ownership as though I'm a piece of furniture."
I gave him a warning look.
"Please, Bartleby. Not now."
He subsided, though his whiskers were twitching irritably.
I turned back to Natalie.
"Look, I'm sorry you're disappointed," I told her. "I really am. But I didn't take anything away from you. I didn't even know I was a witch until I got to Hidden Hollow!"
"Exactly!" she exclaimed. "And that's the problem! You don't even appreciate what you've got!"
I stared at her, feeling my own temper beginning to rise.
"Of course I appreciate it! Natalie, I've been miserable for days because I couldn't get back there!"
"Well, you should have thought about that before you took everything that ought to have been mine!"
I took a deep breath, trying to keep my voice calm.
"Can I please just see the key?"
She looked at me for a long moment, then, very slowly, she smiled in a very unpleasant way.
"Why, of course you can see it."
She reached into the pocket of her sweater and pulled out a large iron key. My heart leaped. It was the Blackthorn key! There was no mistaking the heavy old-fashioned shape or the intricate Gryphon carved into the handle, with its wings spread wide.
"Oh my God!" I exclaimed, taking a step towards her. "Natalie, that's it! That's my key!"
I held out my hand, but instead of giving it to me, she pulled it back.
"Not so fast."
I frowned.
"What do you mean?"