Page 21
She pulled a paper off the top. “Is this from freshman year?” It was an assignment that she and Blake had passed back and forth in Music Theory I.
Blake was nodding when she looked up. He ran a hand through his disheveled hair and pointed to the remaining stack. “Yeah, there are a few of those in there. My favorite is the one where we start arguing about the best taco fast-food restaurants.”
“And I had no idea that any existed outside of Taco Bell,” she recalled, dusting off the emotions layered atop those memories.
“Exactly.” He reached over her and pulled something else out. “I also have this little beauty.”
“No way,” Zara shrieked. “My Rice student ID!”
He laughed at her reaction, whatever reservations he’d kept falling away. “I don’t think I used my own since we traded junior year.”
“I will tell you”—she laughed with him—“Blake Thatcher checked out a surprising amount of harp books for being a trumpet major.”
He shook his head. “How did we even get away with that?”
“We kinda ruled that school.”
He reached in again and pulled out the stuffed owl that had been a gift from Blake’s sister when he got accepted.
Zara did not skip a beat before grabbing it from him and wrapping it in a hug. “Stewie!”
The Rice mascot was named Sammy, but Zara had called that stuffed owl Stewie and no one had ever dared correct her. Blake certainly wasn’t going to start now.
“I swore I told Nolan to grab him,” she said, “but he said Stewie wasn’t on the couch. I figured you finally stole him back.”
He shook his head. “Nope. He was there waiting for you. I almost sent him but—”
“No.” Zara nodded. “Yeah I, um, understand.”
Blake stared at Zara as she baby-talked the stuffed animal, her voice soft and apologetic. “Aw, you cutie pie. I never meant to leave you. I am so, so sorry.”
She had been infatuated with the owl from the minute she saw it perched on Blake’s dorm room twin. In all honesty, Blake would have probably donated it after freshman year had Zara not loved it so much. When he, Nolan, and Zara moved into the house together, Stewie had taken his rightful place as the centerpiece of the couch.
“You should take him, Z,” Blake said.
“Really?” The face Zara gave him was one of pure joy. He matched it with one of his own. A long time ago, that look had been a daily occurrence.
“So,” Blake said, “should we go find that bearded guy and bid on other people’s mistakes?”
The moment vanished.
“I’ve got plans—”
“I was just joking,” he tried covering.
Zara broke it first. “It’s just. I have this thing. On Wednesdays.”
“It’s really okay,” Blake said, his words picking up pace. “I would love to catch up soon. Hear more about that ballet gig?”
“Maybe.”
The quiet that followed was awkward. Heavy in a way that made them suddenly aware of the narrowness of the storage room. The slight flicker of the fluorescence. Zara started shuffling through the box again, if only to have something else to think about.
But the memories were too much. Coming too fast and sharp. Blake being such an asshole, you had no choice but to laugh at him. Their late nights on the couch. Flashes of laughter in the kitchen. Arguments that had felt forever but not this long. Not this stretched out.
This one that had ruined it all.
And suddenly, the bad memories rushed in, rewriting the good. Insistent upon being remembered last. Screaming at her to get away from Blake. The one who had ruined this box and that house and her future.