Page 71
My hand comes up off my leg to do something about it, and I put it back down on my leg.
There isn't a way through this where I step in.
He's her brother, he's owed every word of it, and I'm the man who walked him through that door.
So I stand against the boards with my hat in both hands and let it happen to her.
Somewhere in the middle of it, I lose track of what separates me from the men upstairs who signed her paper.
Then she says, "I'm not going to tell you it was worth it."
"I didn't ask you that."
"I know. I'm telling you anyway." She opens her eyes. "Because you're going to ask yourself for the rest of your life whether it was, and I want you to have it from me that it wasn't, so you don't have to carry that part yourself."
Toby stands there with the tears running down into his collar and his hat crushed up in both hands.
"You should've come home," he says.
"Yes."
"That's it? Yes?" His voice comes up for the first time in the room and breaks on the second word.
"There isn't anything after yes."
He puts his hat on.
He's twenty-five years old, and he puts his hat on in front of his sister like a man leaving a bank.
Then he looks at me.
"Mr. Doyle."
"Toby." I get my chin up for him, which is the least a man can do standing where I'm standing.
"Is she going to be all right?"
And I stand there in a shed with my hat in my hand and I lie to a twenty-five-year-old boy who's run my cattle for years and never once asked me for anything.
"Yeah, son. She is."
It comes out level, the way everything comes out of me, and that's the trouble with being what I am.
There's a list in me of what I've said that wasn't true, and nearly all of it was business.
This one's going somewhere else.
He says yes, sir, and he goes out past me.
His boots go off across the gravel toward the bunkhouse, and he doesn't look back at either one of us.
She hasn't moved her hand off the wall.
"What's on that board?"
"Nothing." She says it to the wall and not to me.
"All right."