Page 64
Jennie went back into ProQuest and searched “Marcella Porter.” She was overwhelmed by hundreds of returned hits. Her laptop’s clock informed her she had forty minutes until the library closed at eight. She would need to prioritize. She filtered the results for articles written in 1909–1910, the period just after the Midnight was stolen. Jennie suppressed a laugh as she read through a seriously old-timey scandal about a woman walking around a maze with a gardener. Girl, you were born in the wrong time, she thought. My mother would’ve been thrilled if I met a nice gardener. Remembering the locket, she clicked on an article entitled “Ball of the Century,” and was drawn into a curious description of the extravagant party, which had been held at the Porters’ Bronx estate:
The guests were given the directive to “dress as your truest self” and the costumes were diverse and inventive. Press was not allowed, and although this reporter interviewed no less than a dozen attendees, they were strangely bereft of details, their memories uncharacteristically cloudy. We were at least able to glean that Porter House itself was filled with flowers in every single room, and Miss Porter and her companion, Miss Anneke de Groot of Holland, wore dark and flowing ensembles and were very beautiful.
Jennie toggled over to the internet to see if the mansion was still standing. She learned that, after falling into ruin, the grand home had been torn down to make way for the city’s new wholesale produce market. Although, according to one article the mansion’s stone cellar was too solid to be easily demolished and was incorporated into the foundations of one of the new market buildings. Jennie clicked to the email draft where she was taking notes. Porter mansion cellar remains intact under Hunts Point Produce Market? Something to find up there? When she had more time, she’d make an appointment with the Bronx County Historical Society and see what they could tell her about the Porter family.
Jennie checked her clock again. She’d spent twenty minutes going down the rabbit hole of the Porter mansion. Focus. She clicked on the next “Marcella Porter” hit, another article dated 1910.
After falling out with her father, industrialist Eugene T. Porter, over his treatment of coal miners, Miss Porter disavowed her fortune and has found success on the stage. While we wish Miss Porter the best, we worry she will end up a cautionary tale; a reminder to fathers to keep a tight rein on their daughters, particularly when they are of the marrying age.
Jennie scoffed, indignant on Marcella’s behalf, one hundred years later. Having gone from “success” to “cautionary tale” herself—albeit on a much smaller stage—Jennie knew there must be more to the story. She tried to click forward to the next article. But there wasn’t one.
Strange, she thought. The article she’d just read was the last entry in the database for Marcella Porter. Surely a scandalous story like that, a famous woman . . . people didn’t just stop writing about it. But there was nothing. No follow-up on what happened to Marcella or her theater career. Not even an obituary. Perhaps she married and changed her name? Jennie searched the library’s catalogue. There was not one book written about the Porter family. This was unusual for a family who was once on par with Vanderbilts and Morgans and Rockefellers.
Back to ProQuest. She quickly searched “Lana LaValle” and was met with the opposite scenario: there was nothing written about her early life and rise to stardom. She appeared in 1911, fully formed as a celebrated actress. Just when Marcella disappeared from the record. Could Marcella have somehow taken on a new identity without anyone noticing?
The articles that did exist about Lana were not particularly illuminating. They praised her performances in Oh My Gal!, detailing the jewelry she wore and noting that each piece was gifted by a different lover. But there was no mention of the Midnight, or any other blue diamond. Lastly, an obituary recorded her death in an automobile accident in 1912. Like many people of note from the time, she was interred at Green-Wood Cemetery. Poor thing, thought Jennie, shivering. If she was the type to believe in cursed diamonds, the fates of Marcella and Lana might convince her to seek her fortune elsewhere. One died violently at the height of her fame, the other just . . . disappeared.
“The library will be closing in ten minutes!” called a guard. “Please make your way to the exits.”
Jennie started in her seat and rushed one more search for “Lana LaValle” in the library’s own catalogue, in case there was a physical archive. As luck would have it, there was. One big, fat, glorious hit. An archive kept at the Library for the Performing Arts up at Lincoln Center:
Subject: LaValle, Lana
Creator: CG Collection
Physical Description: 1 linear foot (1 Box containing letters & scrapbook)
Access to Materials: Off-Site. Request in-person research appointment.
Jennie sent a quick email to the provided address requesting an appointment as soon as possible.
“Time to go! Some of us have kids to cook dinner for.”
She looked up to find an annoyed security guard standing a few feet away. She was the only patron still in the reading room. “Sorry! Leaving now.” She titled her research email “Midnight Diamond Notes,” sent it to herself, then made her way to the exit, thinking about the LaValle archive. It wasn’t uncommon, she knew, for donated papers to be shelved without anybody reading through them. If fortune was with her, just maybe there would be something in those letters that explained why Lana had the Midnight.
In the chilly, nighttime bustle of Fifth Avenue, the logic of the library receded. The wild thrill of potential returned. Jennie was very possibly the only one in the world who still knew that the Midnight Diamond had not disappeared after it was stolen, but had been paraded around the New York stage. She just had to stay ahead of Maurice and Lee, and maybe it could be hers. She thought automatically about sharing this discovery with Pete, what insights he might share about the possible connection between Marcella and Lana. And just as quickly, she realized she would never get the chance. Not safe, he had written. Was he talking about a person? Or the diamond itself? Could her brilliant, logical friend really have been frightened by an ancient curse?
She popped her collar against the wind and trudged toward the subway. Whatever Peter had found in Little Hope, others had wanted for themselves. She was sure of this now. And it was up to her to make sure they didn’t get it.
26
The Wheel of Fortune
Marcella
Victoria Palmetto, Banking Heiress, Elopes with Irish Chauffeur.
The heroine (Catholic) and her hero (Protestant) had slipped away from her father (enraged). The story of their doomed romance endeared them to lovers of gossip across the United States. The columns so recently infatuated with Marcella now heaped their praise upon Miss Palmetto. When Marcella took the stage that evening, she waited for the familiar, electric thrill to radiate out from the hidden Midnight, to imbue her with talent and with presence. But it never came. She stood there, feeling ordinary and slightly nervous. Then she came in a full measure late to her solo, distracted by the half-full and yawning audience. Not even a daisy was thrown at curtain call.
“If we sing loud enough tomorrow, nobody will have to listen to her squawking,” said one of the chorus girls, not bothering to keep her voice down. That evening, Marcella lingered in her dressing room, but no gentlemen came to invite her to dinner. She returned alone to her hotel, where Anneke was reading in their parlor.
“Tell me honestly,” she said, “am I a good singer?”
“That’s not the point,” said Anneke. “The point is you are you.”
Marcella slumped into a chair with the sickening realization that the stone had grown bored with her and resented its hiding place. All night she stroked it and whispered to it, asking for its forgiveness. Asking it to understand that for her to wear it openly was a danger to them both.
The next day, the diamond sat like ice on her skin, poisoning Marcella with stage fright, sending her wretched awareness of how foolish she appeared to the entire world. Her eyes squinted, her voice cracked, the flesh on her upper arms wobbled. Her foot caught on a loose board, and she tripped to the front of the stage, kicking out one of the footlights and nearly falling into the orchestra pit. The chorus girls joined the audience in laughing at her. The show’s proprietor bumped her to the middle of the first act. Victoria Palmetto would take the finale, from now on. It turned out she was legitimately talented in the vocal department, and her chauffeur paramour could play the piano to boot! This demotion came with a pay cut that no amount of haranguing on Anneke’s part could reverse. Marcella was so awful that even after months as a professional actress, she couldn’t even hack it at the far end of the chorus line. A few days later, she was told that if her name wasn’t in the papers, her person had no business on the stage.