Page 21
“I know that,” she said, waving one hand slightly as if dismissing the obvious. “I meant in general. What are they like?”
I focused on the cookie in front of me, adding another layer of frosting that didn’t need to be there.
“Anonymous,” I repeated.
She stopped what she was doing entirely now.
“That’s not a personality trait.”
“It’s a defining characteristic in this context.”
I could feel her looking at me, evaluating, deciding whether I was being intentionally difficult or if this was just my baseline operating mode.
“Fine,” she said finally, picking her piping bag back up. “Be mysterious. That’s very on brand for you.”
It should have felt like a dismissal, but if anything, it sounded like interest.
I was about to respond when she reached for a different piping bag and squeezed a small amount of red frosting onto the edge of her paper plate to test the flow. She adjusted her grip, frowned slightly at the consistency, and then, in the process of angling the tip, caught it against the rim of the bowl beside her.
A small dot of frosting landed on the tip of her nose.
She didn’t notice.
I considered letting it go, saying nothing, allowing her to realize it on her own in thirty seconds or so and laugh it off with someone else at the table. That would’ve been consistent with the version of this dynamic we had maintained for a year.
Instead, I reached out.
“Don’t move,” I said.
She stilled, her hand pausing midair with the piping bag still angled toward the cookie. My hand hovered for a moment, close enough to register the warmth coming off her skin, before I closed the gap and brushed the frosting away with my thumb.
The contact was brief, and yet my brain lingered on it longer than necessary, filling in details that had no immediate relevance. The curve of her cheek. The way she didn’t pull back instantly.
I considered moving my hand along her jaw and resting my thumb just under her cheekbone. The one time she had kissed me, it had taken me by surprise. I had kissed back, but not the way I fully would have if I had registered it faster.
I wanted to kiss her again. I wanted to do more than kiss her. I wanted to pull her against the counter and find out if she’d make that surprised sound again when I touched her. I wanted to see what would happen if I stopped pretending this tension between us was manageable.
But I did the wise thing and pulled my hand back.
“You had frosting on your nose,” I said, clearing my throat slightly as I dropped my hand to my side.
“I figured,” she replied, but her voice had shifted, quieter than before, like something in her had momentarily lost its footing.
She blinked once before she turned back to the table, reaching for her cookie with a hint of extra focus.
The room continued around us. Debates over whether green or red frosting was more festive went around the table, but it felt slightly removed, like we were half a step outside of it.
Cassie finished her ornament and set it aside, already reaching for another cookie without hesitation.
“You know,” I said, nodding toward the row of decorated cookies she’d accumulated, “those are good.”
Her eyes narrowed slightly, the corner of her mouth twitching like she didn’t fully trust where the sentence was headed.
“Is that a compliment from Alex Connors I hear?”
I let out a short laugh. “I’m capable of saying nice things.”
“You had me fooled,” she muttered, turning back to her cookie.