Page 36
But as we step outside and start to head home, the chaos of the day must be catching up to her because I notice she’s slowing down, rubbing her eyes.
I glance down at her, already knowing. “Wanna ride?” She doesn’t even hesitate, she nods sleepily, lifting her arms. I scoop her up easily, settling her against my chest, and she lets out this soft little sigh. Her arms loop loosely around my neck, her face tucking into the space beneath my jaw. “Sleepy?”
“Mmmhmm,” she whispers, already halfway gone. “Firefighting is a… lotta work.”
A quiet laugh slips out of me as I adjust my hold on her, one hand coming up to steady the helmet she’s still wearing like it’s part of her uniform now. “Sure is, kiddo.”
The walk back is slower, quieter, and after a few minutes, her weight settles fully against me, her breathing evening out, soft and steady against my neck. Every now and then she shifts, pressing a little closer, like she’s making sure I’m still there. Something about it, her trust in me… it does something to me.
By the time we get back to my apartment, she’s asleep, her little body limp in my arms. I carry her inside and gently lay her down on the couch careful not to wake her, the fire helmet still gripped tightly in her tiny hands as I cover her with a blanket. Paige walks in a short time later, halting in the doorway as she takes in the sight. Zoey, peacefully asleep with her arms wrapped around the helmet, while I’m sitting on the couch next to her, keeping watch as if she means the world to me. Well, I think she’s starting to.
Paige exhales softly, her gaze softening as she looks at her daughter. “Looks like she had a full day.”
“She did,” I reply, a fond smile tugging at my lips. “She’s… pretty amazing.”
Paige meets my eyes, her expression unreadable for a moment, before she offers a quiet, “Thank you, Zach.”
I nod, my voice gentle. “You don’t have to thank me, Paige. I’ll be here for her, for both of you.” And I mean that, because somewhere between the questions about unicorns and the sirens this stopped feeling like a favor and started feeling a lot more like a family.
18
Skeletons In The Closet
PAIGE
After Zoey drifts off to sleep on the nights when Zach is home, we’ve fallen into a rhythm neither of us really talks about but feels almost sacred. We “watch” TV, though neither of us is paying attention. The screen flickers light across the room, but our eyes are on each other, the space between us charged with the quiet intimacy of our shared secrets. Some nights, it’s light, stories about work, memories from our childhoods, small jokes, laughter that makes the hard edges of the days softer. But other nights like tonight it’s different, like the nights when Zach listens to me when I talk about my mom and end in tears. The air is heavier, thicker with truths unsaid, sitting just beneath the surface, waiting for someone to finally reach for them.
The glow from the television washes over Zach’s face, catching the line of his jaw, the quiet intensity in his eyes. One arm is stretched along the back of the couch, close enough that I can feel his warmth without him even trying. I knew this moment was coming since his bond with Zoey has only grown since we got here. I feel it long before he even says the words. I can see it in the way he’s been watching us tonight, the quiet wonder in his expression. I knew he'd be curious after spending the day with her, that he'd want to try to understand what kind of man could walk away from someone like her, from someone like me.
“What was he like?” Zach’s voice is low, careful when he asks, but there’s a tightness beneath it, a restrained fury that’s already forming inside him.
My stomach clenches immediately. I don’t have to ask to know who he means. “Trevor?” I swallow, the name bitter on my tongue. I hate that it still lingers, that it still holds weight in my mind.
Zach doesn’t react outwardly, but I can see the subtle tightening of his jaw, the flicker of something dark in his eyes when he nods. “You never talk about him.”
“Because he doesn’t deserve to be talked about.” The words slip out, too sharp, too raw. I exhale slowly, steadying myself, my fingers absentmindedly picking at the seam of my leggings. Zach doesn’t push, he doesn’t rush me, he simply waits, and that makes it harder for me to keep this inside. “We met when I was only twenty-one,” I start quietly. “He was older, thirty. Mature, sophisticated. He had this way of making me feel like it felt like I was chosen, and I think that’s what drew me to him at first. He was so confident and charming in a way that seemed effortless. I let myself fall for him because… because he made me feel seen, important and I thought… I thought it was enough.” Zach’s eyes darken, his posture shifting slightly, like he’s bracing for impact. “I never realized just how much I didn’t know about him,” my voice wavering before I continue.
“He lived upstate, and he'd commute into the city. It was... easier that way, I guess, easier for him to hide who he really was, easier for me not to see the full picture, easier for me to miss the obvious signs. The distance helped him keep parts of his real self hidden from me. At first, I thought it was just logistics, that we were still trying to figure things out, but now, looking back, I should’ve seen through the cracks. The nights he’d never answer his phone, the things that just never quite made sense, the way he always deflected when I asked about his past or his family. He played that game with me for over a year.” Zach’s jaw tightens slightly, and I wonder if he’s already guessed where this is going.
“Then I found out I was pregnant and I knew… I figured he’d be shocked at first, maybe scared, but I thought he’d come around. I thought he wanted to be with me, that he’d wanted a family, I thought he loved me.” I shake my head, and a hollow laugh that’s void of humor slips out before I can stop it. “But I was so naive.” He shifts again, a tension coiling in his shoulders. “I told him,” I whisper, and my throat tightens. “I told him I was pregnant, and before I could even finish the sentence, before I could even say I wanted us to be a family—” I swallow the lump in my throat and push forward, “—he told me he was married, that he already had a family.”
Zach’s fingers dig into his knee, his expression hardening, and his entire body is coiled so tightly, like he’s ready to hit something. “He was married? Are you fucking kidding me?” His voice is low, dangerous, and it sends a shiver through me, not of fear, but of something else, something like relief, because he’s angry for me, because someone else besides my friends is finally angry for me.
I shake my head, the tears that I’ve been fighting so hard to hold back start to burn in my eyes. “He had a wife, three kids, a whole life that I didn’t even know about, and I was just something fun for him, something on the side, just... just a secret to him, something to be hidden away. Zoey, me, he said he wanted nothing to do with it.” I feel my voice crack, but I keep going, the words tumbling out, each word heavier than the last. “He told me he didn’t want me to keep the baby, that if anyone found out it would ruin everything, so he told me to... to get rid of it.”
Zach’s head jerks up at that, his eyes flashing with pure rage. “He told you to—” he cuts himself off, like he can’t even say the words, like they physically hurt him. I nod and Zach growls something furiously under his breath. His hands are shaking, his body practically vibrating with anger. “That piece of shit.” His voice is thick with barely contained fury. “He lied to you, he tricked you , he fucking—” He inhales sharply, trying to rein himself in. “Paige, I swear to God—” I blink rapidly, trying to push back the tears, but one slips free, and before I can wipe it away, Zach is already there, his thumb catching it, his touch impossibly soft. The contrast between his rage and his gentleness sends something through me.
“I let myself believe it was real,” I whisper, my voice breaking. “I thought—” I shake my head, my breath hitching. “And when I told him I wasn’t getting rid of her, he completely disappeared, blocked my number, made it very clear that I wasn’t going to ruin his life.” I let out a humorless laugh. “Like I was the one who lied, like I was the one who betrayed him. I never saw him again after that, and to this day I don’t regret it,” I tell him, looking him straight in the eye. “Not one single second of it, not even all the pain, because it gave me Zoey.” I swallow again, the memory rising before I can stop it. “When he left, I thought it was going to be the end of me,” I whisper. “I couldn’t breathe, couldn’t think, I just sat there, replaying everything over in my head, trying to figure out what I’d done wrong. I—I didn’t know what to do.” My voice is barely a whisper. “I thought I'd ruined my own life just by trusting someone. I was terrified,” I admit, my voice dropping softer, more honest, “of what kind of mother I was going to be when I didn’t even know how to take care of myself anymore. I spent nights crying, wondering how I was supposed to do this alone.”
I exhale shakily. “But I wasn’t alone. Baylee, Nia, my neighbor—Mrs. Shirley, they all showed up, they were my anchors, they held me up when I couldn’t stand. They made sure Zoey felt loved, wanted… before she even arrived, they held my hand through every doctor’s appointment, every late-night breakdown, every doubt. They were the ones who helped me prepare, we painted the nursery together, they helped me pick out names. Nia read every parenting book she could find, and Baylee made sure I had all my cravings stocked in the kitchen. I used to think about my mom a lot and how she would’ve been so heartbroken for me if she'd been alive, but she also would’ve told me that I could do this, that I was stronger than I thought.” I meet Zach’s eyes, my breath uneven. “And she was always right. It wasn’t easy, but I prepared, I took on extra clients, I saved everything I could. I read every book, watched every video, because I refused to let my daughter feel unwanted, I refused to let her feel the way her father made me feel. And then... then I saw her.” I close my eyes, remembering that moment, the first time I held Zoey in my arms. “The second I saw her, everything changed, and nothing else mattered. The pain, the heartbreak, the fear, it was all worth it because she was all mine, it didn’t matter how much he didn’t want her because I did.”
Zach pulls back enough to look me in the eyes, his hand still cradling the side of my face, his thumb brushing over my cheek, reverently. “You're the strongest person I know, Paige.” His voice is rough, weighted with emotion. “And he is a fucking idiot, a fucking coward. But I—” He pauses, his eyes flicker to my lips for the briefest second before locking back onto my eyes, looking directly at me, “—I want you, all of you, I want both of you, and no part of either one of you is a mistake.”
His grip tightens slightly, like he’s anchoring me, like he wants to take even a fraction of my pain as his own, then, slowly, deliberately, he lifts my hand to his lips, pressing the softest kiss to the inside of my wrist. The touch is barely there, but it sears into me, a quiet promise, a silent vow, and for the first time in a long time, I feel something I didn’t think I’d ever feel again, I don’t feel like a mistake, I feel safe, I feel seen, I feel wanted.
19
Not So Sneaky Stolen Hearts