AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

Playing My Holiday

Page 32

by J. Saman

I shift on the bed and stare down at my hands, not knowing what to say, my stomach in knots. “I’m sorry. I… I didn’t know how to tell ye. I didn’t think about it much, truth be told. I didn’t want anyone else, male or female, and so to me, it didn’t matter.”

“I understand why you didn’t tell me.”

I blink up at her, feeling my eyes glass over. “Ye do?”

She nods. “Yeah. That’s not a small thing to tell someone when you’re first dating. Especially for a professional athlete. I can’t imagine that’s common. It’s not in the US for sure.”

A tear hits my cheek, and she reaches up to wipe it away. I don’t deserve her tenderness. Not even a little.

My throat thickens. “Kyren and I… we… well, he was more than my best mate. Especially once I hit sixteen.”

“I wish you had told me about him.”

My voice catches in my throat, shame making it difficult to speak. Difficult to swallow. “I didn’t know how. I didn’t even know what I’d say. We’d just gotten engaged, and I didn’t want ye to think that I still loved him or that I’d cheat on ye, because I wouldn’t.” I cup her face. “Ally, not ever. I love you. With all my heart. Ye’re all that I want.”

“Do you still love him?”

My eyes close, and I release a breath. “No. I hate him or am angry with him or maybe both. Any affection is nostalgia. Is the memory of a boy and his best friend who became his lover. I loved him, and he broke my heart. More than once. He did it because it was the right thing to do, but it still cut.”

“It still cuts.”

I don’t know what to say. It does. It shouldn’t, but it does, and I hate that it does because she sees it. It’ll shake her faith in me and what we have. I could lose her over it.

“So last night in the hotel room…”

I heave a breath and fall back onto the bed, my fists going to my eyes. “It’s complicated. I don’t know. I hated him touching ye and yet it turned me on, as I said. I liked the idea of watching him with ye. Of ye looking at me while he was touching you. Of using that as a way to do other things. Dirty things. Maybe I’m sick.”

She rolls over and props herself up on her side. “It turned me on too. You know that.”

“I know that.”

“Were you thinking about being with him?”

Fuck. “Not exactly. Only in the way we were talking about it. Nothing else. I swear. I’d never hurt ye. Not for the world. Ye’re all that I want. Please, please know that.”

She’s quiet for a moment, and tears are coming that I can’t stop. I don’t know what I’d do if she left me. My world would end. It would be just as bleak and black as when Kyren did it. I barely survived that, and I don’t think I could survive without her.

“Ally, please, I love ye. I’m sorry.”

Her hand touches mine, and my eyes snap open. I twist my wrist to take her hand as I study her face. “I’m sorry I dragged you here,” she says, and the shock of her apology has my mouth gaping. “I thought you were missing your best friend. I didn’t realize he was your former lover. He’s bisexual then too?”

“No. He was never attracted to other men. It was only me.” Which made me feel special to him. Like I was his soulmate, and we transcended gender or rules.

She flops back. “I’m not jealous. I should be, right? How crazy is it that I’m not? Or maybe I am, but it’s different. Like, I want to be part of it. Part of that love and your history with him. I feel more like an outsider to your inside with him than I worry you’re going to fall in love with him and leave me. It makes no sense.”

“Because I’d never leave ye for him, and ye know I won’t cheat. Maybe that’s the difference.”

“Maybe…” Her voice trails off. “Let’s go to bed. I need to sleep and think about this tomorrow when I’m sober.”

“Ally…”

“It’s okay. I think.” She sighs. “Just give me tonight, okay? Please.”

“Whatever ye need.”

I’m falling apart, but I do what she asks because it’s more than I deserve. She’s still here. She’s climbing into bed beside me, but she doesn’t kiss me, and I don’t push it. He had no right to do this. To bring us here and to kiss me. Was this about an apology? Or something else? I’ve seen the way he looks at Ally. The things he says to her.

He wants her.