Page 60
“I don’t mind…” But my lips are already itching just thinking about the oil that’s probably all over that drink.
“It’s probably a mild allergy,” he continues smoothly. “You wouldn’t want to kill your hostess, would you?”
Chapter 20
Nate
I don’t like how Campbell calls her Cass. I don’t like the way Theo smiles at her. I really don’t like that I’m not even sure which of them is her date, or the niggling feeling that maybe neither of them really is, and I’ve brought Shaye for no reason other than Cassie assumed she was my date.
And then Shaye played along since she was unexpectedly available.
But right now, I wish they were all gone.
“I’m going to get some food,” I mutter.
Campbell interrupted a moment where I could have told Cassie that I wanted to spend the day with her family today. Because they’re my family, too. Because she’s my family, forever.
“Great idea,” Campbell says, not taking a hint in the slightest. “Oh, are those oatmeal chocolate chip cookies?”
I start to reach for one as well.
Cassie nods. “With raisins, too.”
I pause, my hand hovering over the cookies. But then I grab one.
She twists, giving me a look of surprise. “Really?”
“Maybe I’ll like them.”
“You hate raisins.”
“Is that why you put them in the cookies?” I take a big bite. “Delicious.”
And it is, surprisingly. The squishy raisin takes a second to get used to, and I can’t ever see it being a flavour I like, but packed in there with chocolate chips, it’s giving a festive twist on an otherwise standard cookie. And whatever spices she put in the chewy, dense treat make it easy to take a second bite.
When I finish, I grab a second and put it on a plate along with some crackers and cheese, veggies and dip, and some massive-looking shrimp.
Shaye catches my eye and I hold up the plate, offering to share. It’s like watching myself from a distance, play-acting.
She grins and joins me, taking a plate of her own. “Having fun yet?”
“An absolute blast.”
“Cassie can’t stop looking at you.”
That’s not true. She locks eyes with Theo or Campbell, and gets lost in their attention. Which she deserves, but it’s fucking hard to witness. “I don’t need your sympathy lies.”
“As the game just determined, you’re a very good arbiter of the truth. Why can’t you see it with your wife?”
I grit my teeth.
“I might get a ride home with Ben,” she whispers. “So you can stay later.”
If my jaw wasn’t locked tight, I’d laugh. The last thing Cassie wants is for me to stay late tonight.
“Our next game is a collaborative one.” Jules waves a bundle of index cards in the air. In her other hand is a vintage Tupperware recipe box that matches the index cards exactly. “This is a two-part game! Don’t worry, Ben, we’ll still have a winner and a loser. I know how much you like that.”
Cassie sighs her sister’s name.