Page 107
I wait for her to pull away.
She doesn’t.
Her eyes gleam with an emotion that confuses the shit out of me—sorrow, twisted up with hope and longing. “When has it ever mattered what I want?”
A humorless laugh escapes me. “Charlie.” My gloved hand lifts to cup her cheek. “What you want is the only thing that’s ever mattered.”
Her eyes flutter closed as she leans into my touch, auburn lashes whispering against her freckled cheeks. When she exhales, it’s shaky—halfway to a sob.
My grip on her tightens, and I drop my forehead to hers.
“That’s the thing, Hunter. It can’t matter. Because wanting things like that, things I can’t control…”
Her body stiffens in a way I’ve been bracing for. She slips from my grasp, but I catch her hand as she goes.
“I can’t survive that again,” she says shakily. She squeezes my hand, then releases it. “It’s better this way.”
I watch in slow motion as her face ices over like the frost on Brie’s porch. The hope and yearning from seconds ago vanish, replaced by a stony defeat that hollows out the merry glow around us.
I’ll be damned if I’ll leave things like this.
“You’re right about a lot of things, Menace,” I say, leaning in. “But on this point, you’re wrong. Being alone isn’t better. Especially not when it’s us.”
All she gives me in return is a sad smile and a head shake.
She’s walking up the steps when I blurt, “Let me show you. Tomorrow night.”
She stops, shoulders sagging.
Fuck. She’s going to say no.
“Please, Char.” My words are quiet. I can’t bear to shout this at her retreating back. “Just—trust me. One night.”
She turns, auburn hair spilling over her shoulder. Our eyes lock.
Then she presses her lips together and dips her chin once.
“Okay.”
Hope flares at that single word.
But it can’t overcome my dread as she disappears inside.
Chapter 28
Hunter
Itraipse through snow-caked pines, eight dogs prancing ahead, two words rattling through my skull.
One night.
I’ve got one night to convince Charlie to give us a shot. To prove the benefits outweigh the risks, which are admittedly sizable. Maybe insurmountable, in her mind.
I can’t blame her—not after the parents she grew up with. I saw enough of their marriage to understand why love feels dangerous to her, but it wasn’t the same as living it. Just like having my family’s house to escape to wasn’t the same as being a Wells.
Now, Hailey and I seem hard-wired for stable monogamous relationships. Hell, I’ve gravitated toward them even when the feelings toward the women I’ve dated weren’t exactly revelatory.
There’s only been one woman I’ve ever been that certain about.