AllFreeNovel Stories worth discovering

You Feel Like Christmas

Page 124

by Christine Drummond

“Don’t apologize. It was cute.”

“Cute?” Again, with the eyebrows. “Lovely. Help me out here, Charlie, because I don’t think either of us want me to repeat that performance.”

I fiddle with the blanket. When I don’t answer, his voice drops an octave, the deep surety rumbling down my spine. “What happened to us?”

My eyes find his, and the answer becomes as clear as the evergreen color. This is Hunter. I’ve always told him everything.

Until six months ago, when something happened I couldn’t tell him. Something that turned into everything.

“I…” I shake my head to clear it. “Fuck, okay. I guess we’re being honest with each other. I’ll just say it.” I meet his eyes again. “I saw this…picture. Of you and, um, what’s her face. Yoga-girl?”

His mouth pops open before transforming into a shit-eating smirk. “You know her name, Menace.”

“Whatever.” I roll my eyes. “I saw a picture of you and Naomi online last summer, and it caught me off guard. I guess I didn’t realize you were seeing each other again.”

Hunter frowns. “We weren’t.”

“Well, you looked mighty cozy in the photo,” I shoot back.

His lips part, and I realize how it sounds.

Jealous. I sound jealous.

Because I was.

“I, um, had kind of a weird reaction to it?” Not sure why it comes out a question. Maybe because I still haven’t fully made sense of that moment, six months ago, even though recent events should make it pretty fucking clear.

His smile is going nowhere. “Such as?”

God, he’s not letting me off easy.

“A deep, immediate, unearned hatred for Naomi,” I admit. “Which would have been easier to rationalize if it hadn’t also felt like someone dropped an anvil on my chest.”

Hunter goes still, his smile vanishing.

“I know it doesn’t make sense,” I say, because it didn’t to me. It was the strongest emotional reaction I’d had in years, more than Brent or any other guy I’d dated had elicited, and it scared the shit out of me. “You’re my best friend. You can date whoever you want. I have no claim on you, no reason to feel anything but happy for you.”

The blanket string twists tighter around my finger.

“But I did. I felt way too much. And the next time you called, I couldn’t pick up. All I could think about was that picture, you smiling and sweaty with your arm around her, and how it made me want to scream. And I knew you’d hear it in my voice.”

“Hear what?” he murmurs.

“That something was off. I was afraid I’d lose my shit on you for no reason.” I force a smile. “So instead, I did the emotionally mature thing and avoided you for six months.”

Hunter’s jaw goes slack, mouth holding its O shape.

“Wow.”

“Yeah.” I suck my top lip behind my teeth and resume tugging that loose blanket string.

“That explains your reaction at WinterFest.”

Right. When I was a huge bitch to Naomi, right before fainting on Hunter. Then she’d gone off and taken it out on his business.

This is why I’d avoided him. Big emotions never end well for me.

When I find his gaze again, he arches a brow. “And yesterday morning?”