Page 168
“I love you, Charlotte Hayes. I’ve loved you since we were kids and you found trouble everywhere we went. I loved you as a theater and chorus-obsessed teenager. You were the first girl I ever loved. Maybe the only girl. Because when I think about loving a woman, nothing can match what I feel for you.”
Her lips part, but no sound comes out.
“So now the ball is in your court. I’d love to say I won’t wait forever, but what the fuck do I know? I’ve waited this long.”
This is where I need to leave it, before I ruin things with more words.
I nod once.
“Merry Christmas, Charlie.”
I open the door, but before it shuts, I think I hear her whisper.
“Merry Christmas, Hunter.”
Chapter 44
Charlie
Iforgot how sad claymation Christmas movies are.
Or maybe that’s just me. I belong on the island of misfit toys. A Charlie-in-the-Box, doomed to live among the other loners who can’t accept love.
Sandwiched between Avery and Connor under a mountain of blankets, that’s my takeaway. Hunter was right. I can’t be fixed. If I couldn’t do it for him, I can’t for anyone.
Worse, I’m trapped in a box of my own making. Nature, nurture—doesn’t matter. Twelve years, and I still haven’t figured out how to accept love.
What right do I have to fix anyone else?
At least existential crises and the holidays go together like cookies and cocoa, both of which we’ve been stuffing our faces with since this movie marathon began.
It might even be a suitable distraction if Mom weren’t hovering, trying to make up for years of shitty parenting by asking if the temperature’s alright, if we need a refill, another pillow or—
“Bathroom,” I grunt after her fifteenth interruption. I wish I could tune her out as easily as the kids have.
Extricating myself from our blanket fort, I storm toward the kitchen, ignoring Brie baking yet another batch of Christmas cookies.
Locked inside the powder room, I wonder what my endgame is.
I have five hours until I need to be in the city for Brent’s final show. I could go in early, but the office will be dead, Daryll’s still out of town, and I’m definitely not in the mood to see my second-tier city “friends” who have no idea what I’ve been dealing with.
Then there’s whether Hunter and Hannah will even show up tonight. Pretty sure Hannah read every awkward silence and glance between us on the porch earlier.
I groan, splash some water on my face, and slink back through the kitchen, only for Brie to stop me in my tracks.
“Here,” she says, shoving a cookie into my mouth. “Eat this. We need to talk.”
She steers me onto her freezing deck, checking to make sure we weren’t followed before quietly sliding the door shut.
“Wha-da—heh—” I say, spraying crumbs everywhere.
“Chew and listen.” She crosses her arms. “I know you’re not happy Mom’s here, but it’s Christmas, and it’s not about us anymore. We’re adults. We had our time. This is about the kids. And while they might not know what’s going on, they can read vibes pretty damn well.”
My chewing turns sheepish. I remember how Avery assumed I’d bailed on her concert because I wasn’t standing with the family. How sad she’d looked.
I’ve disappointed them all enough. I refuse to be my parents. These kids deserve better.
“You’re right,” I say, swallowing the buttery remnants. “I’ll keep my shit together for the next two days.”